
The Vault of Horror
~ the obit ~
The comic began in March 1948 as War Against Crime and ran eleven issues under that name. In 1950 Bill Gaines and his editor Al Feldstein started slipping horror stories into their crime books to see what happened, and with the issue cover-dated April and May 1950 the title was replaced outright. Because second-class postage permits were cheaper to keep than to apply for, the numbering stayed where it was. That is why the first issue of The Vault of Horror is number 12.
It ran bi-monthly for twenty-nine issues under the Vault-Keeper, and it was the quietest of EC's three horror books. Tales from the Crypt had the better brand and The Haunt of Fear had Graham Ingels, while this one had a house style you could identify from across a room: cold and tidy domestic murder, with the violence arriving as the consequence of something a reader had already watched a character decide to do.
The end was industry-wide rather than specific to the title. Congressional subcommittee hearings in April and June 1954 left the comic business badly shaken, and that September the publishers wrote a code for themselves that forbade the words horror and terror in any title. Gaines canceled all three horror books. Issue 40, cover-dated December 1954 and January 1955, was the last.
~ the rap sheet ~
| Born | issue 12, cover-dated April and May 1950, out of War Against Crime |
|---|---|
| Peak | issue 35, February 1954, when its artist became its editor |
| Killed | issue 40, cover-dated December 1954 and January 1955 |
| Lifespan | 29 issues over nearly five years |
| Made by | Bill Gaines and Al Feldstein at EC Comics, drawn by Johnny Craig |
| Killed by | the Comics Code, which banned the word horror from any title |
~ the one man who did it ~
Johnny Craig illustrated every cover of the entire run, all twenty-nine of them, and drew the lead story in every issue except numbers 13 and 33. He also wrote all his own stories except two, which almost nobody at EC did, since Gaines and Feldstein wrote nearly everything in the building. In February 1954, with issue 35, he became the book's editor as well.
That makes The Vault of Horror the closest thing EC had to an auteur title, and it explains why it looks so different from its siblings. Craig's figures stand still. His covers tend to show one person understanding something, usually a second before it stops mattering. The rest of the stable, Jack Kamen and Wally Wood among them, came through on the inside pages, and so did Harvey Kurtzman and Jack Davis, but the front of the book belonged to one man for its whole run.
The outside writers only arrived at the end. Carl Wessler and Jack Oleck were hired in late 1953 and early 1954, which is also when the hearings started, so the title got outside help about a year before it was shut down.
~ borrowed springboards ~
Gaines read widely and openly. The method was to take an existing horror story or film and pull the mechanism out of it, then hand Feldstein something to build on. The sources are traceable issue by issue. "Fitting Punishment" in number 16 comes from Lovecraft's "In the Vault". "Rats Have Sharp Teeth" in number 14 comes from Henry Kuttner's "The Graveyard Rats". Number 13 contains a version of "The Most Dangerous Game" and a version of Stevenson's "The Body Snatcher" in the same issue.
One of those borrowings went badly. Ray Bradbury noticed that an EC title had adapted one of his stories without asking and wrote to the company about it, and instead of a fight the two sides reached an agreement for authorized versions. The Vault of Horror got two of them, "Let's Play Poison" in issue 29 and "The Lake" in issue 31.
~ the film that took the name ~
Amicus made a British anthology film called The Vault of Horror in 1973, directed by Roy Ward Baker, with five men trapped in a basement telling each other their recurring nightmares. Four of the five stories come from Tales from the Crypt and the fifth from Shock SuspenStories. Not one of them came from this comic, and the Vault-Keeper does not appear in it. The title was the only thing used.
~ still in print, never new ~
The reprinting started in 1964, nine years after the cancellation, with Ballantine paperbacks that ran to 1966, and it has not stopped since. Russ Cochran put six issues through his EC Portfolio in the seventies and then collected the whole run in five black-and-white hardbacks in the early eighties. He reprinted it again in comic format with Gladstone in the early nineties, then in proper sequence with Gemstone later that decade, then as six softcover annuals. The recolored EC Archives hardcovers began in 2007, stalled when Gemstone ran out of money, got a second volume out of a boutique imprint in January 2012, and were picked up by Dark Horse in 2014. The complete five volumes came back as oversized paperbacks between 2021 and 2024.
EC itself is publishing again. Oni Press relaunched the line in 2024 and eccomics.com sells new horror anthologies today under names like Epitaphs from the Abyss and Catacomb of Torment. The Vault of Horror appears on that homepage exactly once, in a sentence listing what the old company used to drive into the depraved hearts of a generation. There has been no new issue of it since number 40, which went on sale seventy-one years ago.
~ leave a rose ~
an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.
@}-->-- ... roses left here
~ leave a wreath ~
a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.
paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.
» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe
other phenomena: Will It Blend?, Shutdownify, GivesMeHope, Motion Picture Magazine
also died in the pre-1980s: Atlas/Seaboard Comics, Motion Picture Magazine, Processor Technology
~ leave a note ~
visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.