Murfie

» see murfie.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the eulogy ~

by the time i would have signed up for murfie, mailing a stack of cds from ankara to wisconsin so a warehouse could rip them to flac would have cost more than the discs. the service was an inland-us logistics play. for whatever reason, you boxed your collection, paid for shipping inside the continental forty-eight, the company digitized the discs and shelved them in their madison warehouse. then you streamed your own collection back through a web player. honestly, the whole thing required living within a usps zone where flat-rate boxes made the postage math work.

murfie was founded around 2011 in madison wisconsin by preston austin and matt younkle. anyway, the elevator pitch in the early press was that they were turning a cd collection into a cloud account without you having to rip the discs yourself. the wsj and npr both wrote about it in the early years. for whatever reason, the appeal was the lossless angle, murfie kept the masters as flac rather than transcoding everything down to mp3 the way the early itunes match did. sonos integration in 2014 was the version of the product that landed with audiophiles.

the company was always small. somewhere around fifteen people through the peak years. honestly, the unit economics never quite worked. the rip-and-store cost was front-loaded but the revenue was a monthly subscription, the cds piled up faster than the recurring fees ever covered the warehouse lease. ceo rex mangat left in september 2019. then. november 22 2019 the website went dark and subscribers got an email saying murfie was insolvent.

~ the dossier ~

~ how it landed ~

murfie was an audiophile cult product. that was the visible audience in the forum threads. the appeal sat at the intersection of two things that were already shrinking by 2014, owning physical cds and wanting lossless playback. for whatever reason, most listeners by then had moved to spotify free tier mp3s and stopped caring about the master quality. the murfie subscriber base was the part of the audio crowd that still bought new releases on cd and wanted them available outside the house without leaving the house with a binder full of discs.

murfie also had a marketplace where members could trade ownership of the digitized discs. the company held the physical copy, you transferred title to another murfie account, they re-flagged it on the shelf. it was the closest anyone got to a legal used-mp3 marketplace in the us, because the underlying disc was still a single physical object changing owners. reddit nostalgia threads in 2019 mostly named this as the feature people liked most.

~ the day it died ~

the shutdown was the cleanest version of how a small consumer-storage company collapses in real time. november 22 2019 the email went out. the playback service stopped that day. subscribers were told they had until early december to pay for return shipping at a rate roughly ten times what murfie had previously charged for retrieval, otherwise their discs would be considered abandoned and recycled when the storage lease ended. forum threads from that week have screenshots of the email and rough calculations showing a 500-disc collection would cost a few hundred dollars to retrieve. for whatever reason, the company twitter and facebook accounts disappeared at the same time, reporters from madison.com and tone madison could not reach anyone for comment.

in january 2020 a utah entrepreneur named john fenley bought murfie's assets through his company crossies llc. anyway, fenley moved the 800,000 cds to a property in arkansas. the captimes ran a follow-up in 2022 showing the discs were still in shipping containers, the city of beebe arkansas was suing fenley over the warehouse situation. the streaming service never came back. honestly, the masters survived as a physical pile rather than a cloud archive (or whatever it was called).

~ the long tail ~

murfie is the kind of small consumer company death that happens regularly but rarely gets remembered, the audience was just large enough that some people lost real collections. the audiophile twitter circle still references it as a warning when any small lossless-streaming service launches. the broader pattern was that 2019 was already past the date when "stream your own owned music" was a viable consumer product, qobuz and tidal owned the lossless-streaming category by then on the catalog side, sonos had moved its own audiophile playback story onto those services rather than user-uploaded libraries.

in '26 the murfie name is mostly a footnote in madison-startup retrospectives. the company is what gets cited when someone explains why nobody mails physical media to a third party anymore. the discs themselves are still in arkansas, unindexed, the metadata that mapped cd to subscriber sits on whatever drive fenley still has. honestly that is closer to how a private library dies than to how a streaming service dies (close enough).

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »