Microsoft Bob

» see microsoft.com/bob as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obituary ~

microsoft bob shipped on 10 march 1995. it was a software shell that ran on top of windows 3.1 and windows 95, replacing the desktop with a cartoon home. the start screen was a living room. each room of the house represented a program category. you walked into the study to write letters with the bob word processor and into the den to balance accounts. the kitchen held household records and bob mail. furniture in each room held files. the calendar sat on the desk. the rolodex sat next to it. the metaphor was supposed to make computing legible to a household that did not yet know what a directory was.

the project came out of microsoft user research led by karen fries, drawing on stanford work by clifford nass and byron reeves about how people respond to computers as social actors. the conclusion was that ordinary users wanted a friendly anthropomorphic guide rather than a file system. microsoft built the guide in the form of cartoon assistants, with rover the dog as the default. melinda french, soon to be melinda gates, ran marketing on the launch.

the product flopped. retail data put sales at roughly 58,000 copies in its first year, against microsoft's internal expectations of selling in the millions. reviews were brutal. time magazine later put bob on its list of the fifty worst inventions, calling it a "cutesy" misread of what users wanted. the cartoon metaphor was condescending to anyone past a first computing lesson, and the system requirements for running a graphical shell on top of windows 3.1 were heavy enough that the target audience could not run it well. windows 95 launched five months later with a normal desktop, and bob became immediately redundant. microsoft retired it quietly in early 1996.

i never used microsoft bob. by the time i had a computer with windows on it, the year was 1998 and i was running a normal windows 95 desktop on a slow home pc in turkey. bob had already been dead for two years and had never been localized to turkish anyway. i learned about it later from retro tech writing, the way most people my age learned about it: as the cautionary tale that produced clippy.

~ the case file ~

~ what it was ~

the central idea was a spatial metaphor. a directory tree on disk became a house with rooms. a file inside a directory became an object inside a room. you stored your address book in the rolodex on the desk because that was where rolodexes lived in real life. children's bedrooms held games. the kitchen held household records. the metaphor was pursued literally enough that an external door let you "leave" bob and return to the regular windows desktop, which felt to most users like the only useful exit in the program.

the social-actor concept was the second pillar. each user picked a guide from a list of cartoon characters: rover the dog by default, with scuzz the rat and chaos the cat among the alternatives. the guide sat in a small window and offered help with text balloons. the conceptual descendant of this system shipped two years later in microsoft office as the office assistant, a paperclip named clippy. the rest of bob's design vocabulary did not survive, but the talking-helper-in-the-corner pattern did.

~ what it killed ~

its own design school. bob was the most aggressive single attempt by a major company to replace the desktop metaphor with something domestic. when bob failed at this scale, every subsequent shell-redesign project at microsoft became a smaller, narrower bet. active desktop kept the desktop and added live web tiles. windows xp kept the desktop and reskinned it. nothing again tried to literally replace the desktop with a different physical place.

it also broke the assumption that users wanted simplification at any cost. the field's working theory in the early 1990s was that ordinary users would happily trade power for accessibility. bob proved the opposite by selling badly to exactly the audience it was supposed to delight. a household that had bought a windows pc in 1995 wanted to use windows, even if windows was harder, because windows was what their colleagues at work used. that lesson aged into the design language of every operating system since.

~ what carried over ~

two artifacts that outlived the program by decades. clippy, the office assistant, descended directly from bob's helper concept and ran from office 97 through office 2003, becoming the universally-recognized symbol of "annoying software companion." it has been resurrected as ironic merchandise multiple times. clippy is more famous than bob will ever be.

comic sans is the second artifact. vincent connare worked on bob and noticed that rover the dog's dialogue balloons rendered in times new roman, which looked absurd coming from a cartoon dog. he designed comic sans to fix that mismatch. comic sans missed the bob ship date but landed in windows 95 plus and then in microsoft publisher, and from there into every school flyer and bake-sale poster on earth. one of the most-used and most-mocked typefaces of the modern era was a workaround for a feature in a failed product. that is the bob legacy in one fact.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »