YouTube Rewind

» see youtube.com/user/youtube as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obituary ~

i used youtube heavily through this whole window for tutorials and music. rewind itself sat outside what i opened the app for. it was a marketing video aimed at a creator economy that did not really exist as a culture in turkey at meaningful scale, so the controversy would reach me a week late in a news post rather than in my own feed.

youtube rewind started in december '10 as a four-minute year-end clip of the most-watched videos of the year. by '14 it had grown into a heavily-choreographed production with original music and dozens of creator cameos, made for youtube by portal a interactive. for whatever reason it became the platform's de facto creator yearbook. if your face was in rewind, you had made it that year. if you were not in it, that was the conversation in your community for a week.

the format peaked roughly '14 to '17. then came rewind 2018, "everyone controls rewind." the dislikes started piling up the night it dropped. within a week it had passed the previous youtube dislike record (justin bieber's "baby"), and by the time youtube hid the public dislike counter in late '21 the number sat above 20 million. honestly. the most-disliked video on the site was a video the site had produced about itself.

~ the case file ~

~ how it landed ~

"rewind 2010: year in review" went live on december 13 '10 as a montage of trending clips with no plot. it was a curation exercise dressed up as a youtube branded video, and it set the template that later editions would inflate. the early years were modest. by '13 portal a was producing the videos in partnership with the platform, and cameos were being negotiated in advance.

by '15 to '17 the rewinds were watching like a status board. creators who got in posted screenshots, fans paused frame by frame to identify everyone. the videos were also where youtube tried to signal to advertisers what kind of platform it wanted to be seen as, which kept getting more out of step with what people actually watched.

~ the 2018 video ~

"everyone controls rewind" dropped on december 6 '18. the gap between what youtube wanted to celebrate and what its audience actually watched had finally widened past the point a montage could hide. logan paul's january japan-forest incident was off-limits as a topic, and pewdiepie was not in the cut at all. the cameo list leaned on tv comedians and fortnite-era streamers rather than the creator-economy people who treated rewind as a yearbook.

the dislikes hit the previous youtube record within days. fan-edited "honest rewinds" by pewdiepie and others pulled more views than the official video. the public dislike counter on the original kept ticking up for almost three years, and the eventual decision to hide dislike counts site-wide was widely read as partly downstream of how rewind 2018 had gone.

~ what got buried with it ~

rewind 2019, "for the record," released on december 5 '19 as a sober list of the most-watched videos of the year with no production around it. the 2020 slot was skipped under cover of pandemic. on october 7 '21 youtube posted a short note saying the format had run its course and creators should fill the gap themselves. by december '25 every rewind upload had been unlisted, and in january '26 the videos went fully private. the most-disliked video in youtube history is no longer accessible on the official channel.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »