vcash

» see vcash.my as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the goodbye ~

Digi Telecommunications launched vcash on 10 November 2017 out of Shah Alam, in Selangor. Digi was the Malaysian arm of Telenor, so this was a Norwegian-owned mobile operator deciding that the phone in a Malaysian pocket should also be the wallet in it. The app did QR payments in shops, bill payments, prepaid top-ups and transfers between people. Crucially it was open to anyone, not only to Digi subscribers, which was the right call and also removed the one structural advantage a telco had.

It opened with 500 touch points and 80 merchants nationwide, numbers small enough that the press printed them without rounding. Praveen Rajan ran it as Digi's chief digital officer and Kathryn Lee led the product. The regulatory plumbing sat with Valyou Sdn Bhd, an e-money issuer licensed by Bank Negara Malaysia, because a telco cannot simply decide to hold the public's money. On 6 August 2018 a deal with AmBank put vcash acceptance onto existing point-of-sale terminals, and integrations with iPay88 and MOLPay reached the checkout pages of Malaysian online stores.

Then the market it had helped open filled up. Touch 'n Go launched a wallet with a joint venture behind it and the national toll network in front of it. Grab arrived with a ride-hailing app people already had open for another reason. Boost came in from Axiata. All of them had money to give away and a reason to give it away, and Malaysian shoppers in 2018 and 2019 learned to keep whichever app was paying that week.

~ the chronicle ~

~ what the cashback war cost ~

Digi's own explanation when the end came was that the market had become too competitive, which in this context has a precise meaning. Rivals were handing back a percentage of every transaction, funded from venture rounds raised against future scale, and a telco subsidiary is answerable to a parent company's quarterly numbers rather than to a growth story. Digi watched its quarterly active users fall, and the people walking away were going wherever that week's cashback was.

~ the refund form ~

The notice reached users by SMS at the start of November 2019, saying the wallet would stop on 30 November. Anyone holding a balance filled in a Wallet Balance Refund Form and the money went back to their bank account. No migration into a successor product, no conversion into Digi prepaid credit, no grace period stretching into the next year. The company that had asked Malaysians to keep money inside an app gave the money back and left the category.

That is a cleaner exit than most payment products manage. The usual pattern converts a stranded balance into store credit nobody asked for and dares the holder to spend it. The whole thing took thirty days from announcement to switch-off.

~ who was left standing ~

On 15 January 2020 the Malaysian government opened e-Tunai Rakyat and put thirty ringgit into the e-wallet of every eligible adult who claimed it. The approved wallets were GrabPay and Touch 'n Go eWallet, plus Boost, which had come into the market from Axiata after vcash was already there. A product that had been among the first in the country missed the largest subsidized onboarding event its market would ever hold, by forty-six days.

The domain is still in use and the company that built it is not. Today vcash.my answers under an unrelated owner as a Malaysian personal-finance site explaining remittance markups and the e-wallet rails that did survive, accurate about the market and connected to the dead product by nothing but the name. Digi lasted three more years. It was merged into Celcom on 30 November 2022, which is the same calendar date it had switched the wallet off, and the brand that had launched vcash stopped existing too.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »