Vanguard: Saga of Heroes

» see vanguardsoh.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the eulogy ~

by the time vanguard launched in january 2007 i was 23 on ttnet broadband, watching world of warcraft eat the entire mmo conversation around me. the idea of paying fifty dollars for a buggy fantasy mmo from a former everquest team and then fifteen dollars a month on top was not on my list. wow had reshaped what an mmo had to feel like at launch, and vanguard had not yet figured that out when it shipped.

brad mcquaid, one of everquest's original designers, founded sigil games online in 2002 to build a "spiritual successor" for the players who felt everquest had been simplified by world of warcraft. microsoft signed on as publisher, then dropped the project in 2006. sony online entertainment picked it up. the game shipped on january 30, 2007 in a state widely described as not ready, with severe performance problems and missing content.

initial sales hit about 242,000 copies. roughly 130,000 subscribers stuck around past the free trial, and that number dropped to about 40,000 within a few months. on may 14, 2007, four months after launch, soe acquired sigil and laid off most of the team. soe then spent five years patching the launch state into a working mmo. by 2012 the game was credibly playable. it was also no longer commercially viable.

soe converted vanguard to free-to-play on august 14, 2012. that bought two more years. on july 31, 2014 sony closed the servers along with several other smaller mmos in its catalog, as part of the cleanup before the studio was sold to columbus nova and rebranded as daybreak. vanguard was thirty million dollars of mmo development that never recovered from its first six months.

~ the dossier ~

~ how it landed ~

the launch was the story. early reviews talked about a beautiful unreal-engine-2 world dragged down by serious frame-rate problems and quest content that ran out before mid-level. gamespy gave vanguard its "biggest disappointment of 2007" notice. the player base churned through the trial period and left.

brad mcquaid had positioned vanguard as the mmo for "veterans" who wanted the slower-paced everquest experience back. that audience existed but it was small. wow had moved the genre, and the people who wanted slower mmos were not enough to fill three continents of high-end content that was not finished anyway.

~ the unraveling ~

sony online entertainment bought sigil four months after launch with most of the team being laid off in the process. soe spent five years on patches that fixed performance, finished the missing content, rebalanced the spheres of crafting and diplomacy that vanguard had built next to its combat sphere. by 2012 the game was a credible mmo. by 2012 the genre had also moved twice more, and a fixed-up 2007 mmo was not pulling new subscribers.

the free-to-play conversion in august 2012 kept the lights on for almost two more years. it did not produce growth. soe announced the shutdown in january 2014 alongside the closures of free realms and clone wars adventures, two of its other unprofitable lines.

~ the long tail ~

brad mcquaid passed away in november 2019 while working on pantheon: rise of the fallen, another mmo aimed at the same audience he had tried to serve with vanguard. the pantheon project carried on under his collaborators and is still in extended early-access development as of 2026. unofficial vanguard emulator projects exist but none has reached a stable public release.

vanguard's place in mmo writing is as the canonical "shipped too early" story. the design was thoughtful, the world had real ambition, the team had the resume to back it up. none of that survived seven months of bug reports and bad first impressions in front of the most successful mmo ever launched.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »