
Music Zone
» see musiczone.co.uk as it lived, on the wayback machine
~ the eulogy ~
Music Zone started in 1984 as a market stall in Longsight, Manchester, run by Russ Grainger. The first permanent shop was in Stockport and the proposition never changed much after that: chart CDs and DVDs priced under everyone else, in secondary towns and cheap parades rather than prime high street. For a while it traded as Music Zone Trade Direct, which is about as close to a mission statement as a value retailer needs.
The company went through a £12 million management buyout in 2005, led by managing director Steve Oliver and backed by Lloyds Development Capital. The accounts for the twelve months to 31 May that year are worth reading slowly: £70.4 million of sales and a pre-tax loss of four thousand pounds. Seventy million pounds through the tills to land four grand underwater. A chain running on that margin has no cushion between a weak quarter and insolvency, and the lender holding its facilities was reading the same accounts.
Then came the acquisition that made it large. MVC called in Kroll just before Christmas 2005, and on 4 January 2006 the administrators sold 41 of its shops to Music Zone, taking 437 MVC staff with them. The stores transferred on Sunday 8 January and opened under Music Zone signage the following morning. That took the estate to around 104 and made Music Zone the third largest specialist entertainment retailer in the United Kingdom, fewer than thirty shops behind Virgin Megastore. It held that position for one year almost to the day.
~ the dossier ~
| Born | 1984, a market stall in Longsight, Manchester |
|---|---|
| Peak | 104 stores, £70.4m turnover, third largest UK entertainment retailer |
| Killed | 3 January 2007 administration, last stores closed 26 January |
| Lifespan | 23 years |
| Made by | Russ Grainger, later Steve Oliver and Lloyds Development Capital |
| Killed by | the Bank of Ireland calling in its facilities after a weak Christmas |
~ what a value chain was actually selling ~
Nobody went to Music Zone for the staff recommendation. You went because the thing you already wanted was four pounds cheaper there, and because there was a branch in a town where HMV had never bothered to open. Books and games filled out the rest of the floor. It was an efficient, unromantic business, and for twenty years it worked exactly as designed.
What killed it was that two bigger systems learned the same trick. Supermarkets put the chart album next to the bread at a price no specialist could match, and the internet took the long tail. A chain whose only argument is price has no second argument. In Turkey through those same years the equivalent shop simply never got built, because by the time anyone might have opened one, an afternoon in an internet cafe had already made the whole category optional.
~ twenty seventh of December ~
Christmas 2006 was weak and the pricing in CDs and DVDs that winter was brutal. On 27 December the Bank of Ireland withdrew the company's loan and its future working capital facilities and moved to recover its debts, without notice, with immediate effect. A retailer in the first week of January is at its most exposed point of the year, with the Christmas stock sold and paid for and the suppliers all still owed. Pull the facility there and there is nothing to pull against.
Music Zone went into administration on 3 January 2007, with Bill Dawson and Nick Dargan of Deloitte appointed joint administrators. Thirty one shops closed two weeks later and 325 people lost their jobs. The remaining 72 traded on for ten days while Deloitte looked for a buyer for the whole thing and did not find one. On 26 January every last store closed, costing another 800 jobs. The head office in Stockport shut on 30 January. Debts came to £31 million.
~ the buyer that died next ~
On 5 February 2007 Fopp announced it was taking 67 of the shops, plus the Stockport head office and warehouse and a second warehouse in Denton. Fopp was the Glasgow chain everyone liked, the one with the three pound reissues and staff who had actually heard the records, and buying a value chain's entire estate out of administration was a reasonable-looking way to triple in size overnight.
It was the thing that killed Fopp. Suppliers who had just been burned by Music Zone would not extend the same credit to the company that had bought its shops, and by March Fopp was already closing the more expensive units it had taken on. On 29 June 2007 Fopp went into administration itself and Ernst & Young were appointed, which closed what was left of the Music Zone estate for the second and final time. HMV later bought the Fopp name and reopened a handful of branches. Nobody bought the Music Zone name at all.
~ leave a rose ~
an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.
@}-->-- ... roses left here
~ leave a wreath ~
a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.
paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.
» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe
other media music: MTV Iggy, Technics Tracks, Simfy, Chuang Yi
also died in the 2000s: QuickCast (クイックキャスト), eXeem, Uproar.com
~ leave a note ~
visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.