Andy's Records

1969 - 2003
dead europe
andy gray was selling secondhand jukebox singles on felixstowe pier in 1969, and by 1992 he ran the largest independent record chain in britain, a title he kept for ten years. forty shops at the peak, most of them in east anglia and the north, every one of them caught between supermarket pricing underneath and the internet above. administrators went in during may 2003 with 23 stores left and about 160 staff. the last ten closed on saturday 13 september.

~ the last words ~

Andy Gray was still at school when he started selling secondhand jukebox 45s and old 78s on Felixstowe Pier in 1969. Within five years he had a stall on Cambridge market and had become, by the BBC's account, the first market trader in Britain with an account at a major record company. The first proper shop opened on Mill Road in Cambridge in the middle of the seventies. The business ran on imports at first, records brought in from Europe cheaply and sold on below what the chains could manage, with the sales patter to match: purveyors of fine music at cheapo prices.

Expansion was slow for a decade and then very fast. By the early eighties there were twelve shops across the east of England, Bury St Edmunds and King's Lynn and Peterborough and Norwich among them, trading as Andy's Records & Video once the format war made tapes worth stocking. The Grays decided southern England was too expensive and pushed into the Midlands and the north instead. In 1992 the chain became the largest independent music retailer in the United Kingdom and stayed that way for ten years. It won Music Week's Independent Retailer award in 1993 and took it again every year to 1999. The slogan moved from "Where music matters" to "Where music REALLY matters", which tells you how confident the place was.

The 40th shop opened in Leamington Spa in November 1999, and that was the top. By then Andy's had stopped being the cheap importer and started competing with HMV and Virgin as a premium retailer, which put it in a position with no good moves in it: too small to buy chart albums at the price the big two paid, too large to go back to undercutting anyone. This was a British problem with a British shape. The music I was buying in Turkey in 2003 did not pass through a chain of shops in East Anglian market towns, and the thing that was doing the actual killing here was the same thing a university student with a connection anywhere in the world was doing at the time, for free.

~ the record ~

Born1969, a stall of secondhand records on Felixstowe Pier
Peak40 stores by November 1999, UK's largest independent music retailer 1992 to 2002
Killed13 September 2003, last stores closed
Lifespan34 years
Made byAndy Gray, later with his brother Billy, trading as AHG Records
Killed bysupermarket pricing and online retail

~ caught in the middle ~

Andy's niche was back catalog. If you wanted a record from eleven years ago rather than eleven days ago, the chains had thin racks and Andy's had deep ones, and the Best Independent Retailer awards came out of exactly that. It is also the niche the internet took first and took completely, because a shop that holds a few thousand titles is competing against a catalog with no shelf limit at all. Amazon had been selling CDs in Britain since 1998.

Supermarkets did the other half. Tesco and Asda used the chart album as a loss leader, which meant the one record a casual buyer wanted was cheaper next to the bread than it was in a shop that existed to sell records. Andy's marketing could not answer it. When the administrators went in, the BBC's report listed the two causes in a single sentence: competition from larger chains, and the sale of music on the internet.

~ the discount that came too late ~

Christmas 2002 was bad, and in January 2003 Gray went back to the thing that had built the business. Thousands of titles were cut: albums that had been £10.99 went to £6.99, the £15.99 and £16.99 tier dropped to £10.99 and £12.99. The shops got new decor and the staff got new uniforms. Four months later the administrators were in, with 23 stores still trading and around 160 people employed, down from 40 stores in 1999. The administrators thought a restructured chain of 14 might come out the other side as a going concern. It did not.

~ after the shutters ~

Every store went up for sale together. HMV and Virgin both came and looked at the estate and both walked away. In July 2003 a southern retailer called Powerplay bought four shops from the administrators, Lowestoft and Bedford and Hull and Loughborough, and added Hereford and Worcester in September; all of them eventually closed too, and Powerplay became an online seller. The rest were shut as unprofitable until ten were left, and those ten spent their last weeks selling the stock off at whatever it would fetch. They closed on Saturday 13 September 2003. The Beverley store was bought out by its own managers and kept going on its own until late 2005.

Andy Gray is still in the record business, from an office in Bury St Edmunds directly behind the old head office. BGO Records reissues back catalog, which is what the shops were best at, and it has become the fourth largest reissue label in Britain. The initials come from The Beat Goes On, the secondhand and deleted specialist he used to run in Cambridge. The retail chain lasted 34 years and the thing it was actually good at outlived it.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a wreath ~

a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.

paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.

» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

other media music: Decillionix, Dragon Magazine, Columbia House, Computer Gaming World

also died in the 2000s: WiMedia Alliance, Empire Sports Network, Official Dreamcast Magazine (UK)

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »