Furl

» see furl.net as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the last words ~

furl was the page-archiving bookmarking site, the one with a single feature the bigger players never matched. when you bookmarked a link, furl saved a full html copy of the page so you could still read it after the original site rotted. delicious did not do that. magnolia did not do that. i had a delicious account through those years anyway. furl was the third bookmarking site i never opened an account on, after [[magnolia]].

mike giles founded furl in 2003 in san francisco. looksmart acquired it in september 2004, which is roughly when it became visible to me through the english-language tech blogs. looksmart at the time was the search directory that had lost to google but still had enough revenue to buy small web 2.0 properties. furl was one of those acquisitions. it ran inside looksmart for almost five years on a budget that was visibly thinner each year.

by late 2006 and through 2007 the site had performance problems. looksmart was not pouring money into it. in march 2009 looksmart sold furl to diigo for equity, which is the kind of deal that means nobody was paying cash for it anymore. diigo migrated the bookmarks over to its own platform and shut furl off on 17 april 2009. the user records moved. the saved-page archives that were the whole point of the service did not.

~ the record ~

~ the early days ~

the period from 2005 to 2007 was the moment when social bookmarking looked like a real category. delicious had the user numbers. magnolia had the design press. furl had the archive layer. the english-language tech blogs wrote about all three as if they were going to coexist, the way mp3 players coexisted before the ipod swallowed the segment.

furl's specific pitch landed with researchers and people who tracked sources. saving a full copy of every page meant your bookmark list still worked after a news site paywalled its archive or a blog disappeared. for academic users and journalists this was load-bearing. for casual users it was a small extra. furl's user base skewed heavily toward the academic-and-journalist end, which is also why nobody ever tried to monetise it through ads.

~ what really happened ~

the march 2009 looksmart-to-diigo announcement was framed as a graceful migration. diigo posted a welcome message to furl users on 16 march 2009 explaining the bookmark-export process. the actual shutdown landed on 17 april 2009. furl's saved pages did not migrate. diigo's own product was a different shape, focused on social annotation and highlighting rather than full-page archiving, and there was no equivalent feature on the receiving side.

people who had been using furl as a personal archive lost most of what they had stored. some of it was recoverable through web caches and exports done before the shutdown date. most of it was not.

~ what got buried with it ~

furl belongs to the cluster of web 2.0 acquisitions that died inside their acquirers. looksmart bought it cheap, ran it on minimum maintenance, then unloaded it to diigo when the maintenance bill no longer made sense. this was the standard fate of mid-tier 2003-2006 web 2.0 properties. bought by a bigger company that did not really want them, then sold or shut down two or three years later.

in the same eighteen-month window that swallowed furl, [[magnolia]] lost its database in a backup failure and went read-only. [[delicious]] got sold by yahoo to avos systems and started its long decline. the bookmarking-as-product category emptied out almost completely by 2010. pinboard, which charged money up front and ran lean, absorbed the technically-inclined survivors and is still alive in 2026 under maciej cegłowski. the furl archive feature, the single thing that distinguished the product, is the one piece nobody rebuilt.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »