C7 Sport

1999 - 2002
dead australia
foxtel would not carry it, so it was sold into about six hundred thousand australian homes while nearly seven hundred thousand more sat on the platform it could not reach. when the football rights went in december 2000 the carriage contracts went with them, and c7 stopped operating on 7 may 2002. seven then sued nineteen respondents for conspiring to kill it. the trial ran a hundred and twenty days, the judgment came to eleven hundred pages, the parties spent two hundred million dollars between them, and seven lost.

~ the obituary ~

When Optus Vision started selling cable television in Australia in September 1995, two of its sports channels came from a joint venture called SportsVision. The shareholder list is worth keeping, because almost everyone on it turns up again later as a party to the same lawsuit: Seven held thirty percent, ESPN twenty-five, Optus Vision twenty-five, and Kerry Packer's PBL the remaining twenty. The channels carried Australian rules, rugby league, the national soccer league and Sheffield Shield cricket, which at that point was a better list than Fox Sports had.

SportsVision ran out of money in 1997. Seven bought the channels, put them inside a subsidiary that had been registered under the name Fanessa Nominees, and began supplying Optus again in August 1998. On 1 March 1999 the whole thing was relaunched under the name C7. A deal with Austar a month later took it out of the three cabled capitals and into most of regional Australia. The naming kept moving after that, C7 Gold and C7 Blue through 2000 and most of 2001, with the actual words C7 Sport only going on screen in November 2001, six months before the end.

The one thing it could not buy was carriage on Foxtel. Foxtel's position was that C7 was an inferior service being offered at an unreasonable price. C7 won two Federal Court actions on the point and still never got on. That left it selling into Optus and Austar, which in December 2000 came to roughly six hundred and sixteen thousand subscriber households between them, while Foxtel had six hundred and ninety-eight thousand of its own and was adding them faster.

Its best moment was the Sydney Olympics in 2000, when it ran two extra channels for the Games and even Foxtel came to the table to negotiate access for its own subscribers. The regulator later made it refund twenty dollars a head to customers who had been told the Olympic package would carry every Australian basketball game, men's and women's, and then found it did not.

~ the case file ~

Born1 March 1999, relaunching the channels Seven had bought out of a collapsed joint venture
Peakaround 616,000 Optus and Austar households in December 2000, against 698,000 on the Foxtel platform it was kept off
Killed7 May 2002, with no carrier left and no revenue
Lifespan3 years and 2 months
Made bySeven Network Limited, through a subsidiary originally registered as Fanessa Nominees
Killed bylosing the AFL and NRL pay rights inside six days in December 2000

~ the two weeks in December ~

On 13 December 2000 the National Rugby League's executive committee accepted Fox Sports' offer for the pay rights from 2001 to 2006. On the numbers the league itself ran, Fox's bid was worth about a hundred and eighty-eight million dollars in present value and C7's was worth three hundred and three million on its best case. C7 bid more and lost, because its offer was tiered on subscriber numbers and the league scored it against a subscriber base under a million. The reason that base was under a million was Foxtel's refusal to carry it.

Six days later the Australian Football League settled the other code. Its own analysis put Seven's offer at two hundred and forty million in present value against the News Limited consortium's three hundred and thirty-nine, and recommended News. The term sheets were executed on 19 December with Lachlan Murdoch signing. Seven had a right to match and spent January arguing about it internally before formally declining on 25 January 2001, largely because of the cost. The same day, News signed the sublicenses that put the games on Nine, on Ten and on Foxtel.

Two weeks before Seven formally declined, an executive inside the company wrote to Kerry Stokes about what to do next. Going legal, he said, was the only commercial avenue, and it was critical to get them with a good old fashioned kick in the balls. That email appears verbatim in the judgment six years later.

~ what was left to show ~

The carriage contracts had been written on the assumption that C7 would be supplying football. Optus stopped broadcasting the channel on 28 March 2002 after a twenty-eight day extension ran out. Austar's agreement expired three days later and was not renewed, for the stated reason that C7 no longer held the AFL pay rights. By early May there was no platform left and no revenue coming in, and on 7 May 2002 the channel ceased operations.

Its own website in February 2002 shows what the last schedule looked like. The lead items are Winter Olympic ice hockey, the women's Australian Open golf from Yarra Yarra, up to three live National Soccer League matches a weekend, and the Pura Cup and ING Cup for the cricket. The listings for that day run ice hockey at one, more Olympics at half past three, golf at half past eight, boxing at nine. The page is still selling subscriptions and still has a button labeled Coming Soon.

~ the biggest case in the country ~

Seven filed on 19 November 2002 against nineteen respondents, a list that eventually included News Limited, Telstra, Foxtel, PBL, Nine, Fox Sports, the rugby league, Optus and Austar. The claim was that they had agreed among themselves to destroy C7. The trial opened on 12 September 2005 and ran for a hundred and twenty hearing days across more than a year. Discovery covered eighty-five thousand documents and nearly six hundred thousand pages. Seven's closing submissions alone ran to a thousand five hundred and fifty-six pages. The damages claim opened at more than one point one billion dollars including interest and had shrunk by the end to somewhere between a hundred and ninety-five and two hundred and twelve million.

Justice Ronald Sackville delivered about eleven hundred pages on 27 July 2007, and the first chapter of it is titled Mega-Litigation and its Discontents. His estimate was that the parties had spent in the order of two hundred million dollars on legal costs, roughly half of it Seven's, and his view of that was that the expenditure of two hundred million dollars on a single piece of litigation was not only extraordinarily wasteful but bordered on the scandalous.

Seven lost on the substance. Even if every one of the consortium respondents had held the objective Seven attributed to them, that of killing C7, achieving it could not have substantially lessened competition in the retail pay television market. On the way there the judgment found that Seven was the author of its own misfortune and far from a helpless victim, and that there was more than a hint of hypocrisy in certain of its contentions. It also found that Kerry Stokes could not be accepted as a reliable witness wherever contemporaneous documents said otherwise.

Seven settled the costs bill at A$23.5 million on 14 September 2007 with News, the two football codes, Ten and Austar. The Full Court dismissed the appeal on 2 December 2009, upholding the result while disagreeing with part of Sackville's reasoning on what the Trade Practices Act required. The channel itself had been off the air for more than seven years by then, and it is remembered in Australia almost entirely as the thing the case was about.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a wreath ~

a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.

paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.

» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

other phenomena: Cambridge Analytica, Swatch Internet Time (.beats), It Died, L!VE TV

also died in the 2000s: Furl, Bulkfeeds, Truemors

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »