Wherehouse Entertainment

1970 - 2003
dead us
leon hartstone opened a record store in gardena in 1970 and called the company integrity entertainment, which it then spent thirty years failing to live up to. two leveraged buyouts, one chapter 11 in delaware, 378 blockbuster music stores bought at exactly the wrong moment, and a lawsuit against four record labels over the right to resell used cds. trans world bought what was left on 14 september 2003 and kept 113 of 148 stores.

~ the last words ~

Wherehouse bought 378 Blockbuster Music stores from Viacom in 1998 and briefly became one of the largest record chains in America. 1998 is also the year a modem in Turkey put me on the internet for the first time, and I would not hear this company's name for another twenty-five years. It never opened a store outside the western United States and it never sold a disc to anybody in Ankara, so what follows is read off paper rather than remembered.

Leon Hartstone opened the first one in Gardena in 1970, a suburb southwest of Los Angeles. He named the parent company Integrity Entertainment Corporation and let the stores carry a pun instead: The Wherehouse. There were over a hundred of them before 1980 was out. Hartstone brought in a Chicago music consultant named Louis Kwiker in 1979, made him president in 1980, then died in 1982 after heart surgery with a will instructing his estate to liquidate for cash. Kwiker assembled an employee stock ownership trust, borrowed seven million dollars from Bank of America to cover the entire purchase price, kept 37 percent for himself and made himself chief executive. The chain had 130 stores at that point. It went public on the American Stock Exchange in 1983 with 126 of them, mostly in California, and by 1987 it had 295 and $225 million in sales.

The next sixteen years are a story about debt rather than about records. Roy Disney's Shamrock Holdings bid for the company in October 1987. Wherehouse escaped into the arms of a New York buyout firm, Adler & Shaykin, at $118 million. Adler & Shaykin pushed Kwiker out in March 1988 and was itself forced to sell in 1992, to a management group backed by Merrill Lynch Capital Partners, for $250 million. On 2 August 1995 the company and its holding parent filed voluntary Chapter 11 petitions in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware. The reorganization plan was confirmed on 7 January 1997 and took effect on the 31st of that month, at which point a Delaware shell called WEI Acquisition Co. bought the assets and renamed itself Wherehouse Entertainment, Inc.

Three years clear of bankruptcy, it spent $122.3 million on Viacom's 378 Blockbuster Music stores in 33 states, closing on 26 October 1998. That bought it 529 stores and $765.9 million of revenue in the year to January 2000, the largest the company ever was and the last good year the American record store had. Revenue fell to $706 million, then to $604 million. It filed Chapter 11 again in January 2003 with 370 stores in 23 states, closed 30 immediately and announced 120 more. On 14 September 2003 Trans World Entertainment agreed to buy substantially all of it for $41 million in cash and assumed liabilities, keeping 113 stores and handing the other 35 to a liquidation joint venture. Nobody has written down when the last storefront came off the signage.

~ the record ~

Born1970 in Gardena, California, as Integrity Entertainment Corporation
Peak529 stores and $765.9 million of revenue in the year to 31 January 2000
Killed14 September 2003, sold out of Chapter 11 to Trans World Entertainment
Lifespan33 years
Made byLeon Hartstone, then a succession of buyout owners
Killed by$250 million of buyout debt meeting the end of the compact disc

~ whose money it was ~

The clearest way to read Wherehouse is as a balance sheet. Each owner paid more for it than the last and funded the difference with debt the stores had to service out of a margin that was already thin. Adler & Shaykin paid $118 million, or $14 a share, in 1988. The 1992 sale went at $250 million, of which $131.4 million immediately went to retiring the existing debt, and the new owners then raised roughly $220 million more in bank loans and bonds on top of it. Three years later the whole structure was in a Delaware courtroom.

The second attempt had the same shape. After the 1998 purchase the company owned 529 stores at a moment when the per-disc economics were about to invert, and it had financed them at the top. By January 2002 it was down to 407 stores, had written off its 49 percent stake in an online venture called CheckOut.com, and had sold 64 Wherehouse Music stores to The Music Network along with the Turtle's brand for about $25.7 million. The net loss that year was $53.7 million on $604 million of revenue.

~ the fight over used cds ~

The one genuinely interesting thing Wherehouse did was pick a fight with the record industry over property rights, and it did it because of a returns policy. In 1991 it let customers return CDs for a full refund. Sony's distribution arm responded by refusing to take back opened discs, which left Wherehouse holding inventory it could only sell cheap. In 1993 it went into the used-CD business properly, the largest chain in America to do so.

The labels understood exactly what was at stake. In May 1993 the distribution arms of Sony, Warner Music, Capitol-EMI and MCA withheld cooperative advertising money from any retailer selling used discs. In June, Garth Brooks announced he would not supply records to stores that did it. In July Wherehouse sued on antitrust grounds, arguing that new-release prices were being held artificially high. Capitol-EMI settled that September and turned the ad money back on. The principle Wherehouse was defending, that a disc you bought is yours to resell, is the same one that would later be argued about MP3s and then about everything else, and the chain defending it was gone within a decade.

~ the last three years ~

By the January 2003 filing the company was operating under a handful of names, almost all of them variations on Wherehouse, with thirteen stores carrying Tu Musica, Xchange, Wherehouse Outlet or Odyssey signage. Jerry Comstock, the chief executive installed the previous June, said the voluntary reorganization was the most effective way to restructure and position the company to compete in what he called the new music industry. The plan was to remodel the survivors and fill them with listening stations and interactive kiosks. Eight months later the assets were sold and the restructuring became somebody else's problem. Trans World Entertainment folded the better Wherehouse locations into its FYE brand and bought Musicland three years after that. It eventually reinvented itself as an Amazon marketplace operator under the name Kaspien.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a wreath ~

a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.

paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.

» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

other dot com: Carolco Pictures, Spirit Airlines, Natural Wonders, TinyOwl

also died in the 2000s: Storage Technology Corporation, Riffage.com, Vindigo

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »