
Tuber
» see txappnet.com as it lived, on the wayback machine
~ the last words ~
Tuber was on the app stores for about two weeks and famous for roughly three days. It was an Android browser in Simplified Chinese, published by a Shanghai company called Fengxuan Information Technology, seventy percent of which belonged to Qihoo 360, one of the largest security software firms in the country. What it did was open the websites that mainland China cannot reach.
Through Tuber you could load Google, YouTube, Twitter, Netflix and Wikipedia. There was no VPN to install and no legal exposure for the user, because the crossing happened on the company's infrastructure rather than on the handset. The catch was that whatever came back had already been filtered. TechCrunch tested it on 9 October 2020 and reported that searches for terms like Tiananmen and Xi Jinping returned nothing at all.
Registration required a phone number, which in China means a verified identity. So the deal was legible to anybody who thought about it for a minute: the outside internet, delivered by a licensed domestic company against your real name, with the sensitive parts taken out before they reached you. Five million people took that deal in two weeks, mostly through Huawei's app store, after articles about it went viral on WeChat.
On 10 October the app was removed from Chinese app stores and stopped operating. Its companion site for desktop users went down with it. When a Bloomberg reporter asked the Foreign Ministry about it on 12 October, spokesperson Zhao Lijian answered that this was not a diplomatic issue and that he did not have the relevant information. He added that China has always managed the internet in accordance with the law, then referred the reporter to the competent department.
~ the record ~
| Born | late September 2020, Android only, Simplified Chinese only |
|---|---|
| Peak | roughly five million downloads, mostly through Huawei's app store |
| Killed | 10 October 2020 |
| Lifespan | about two weeks |
| Made by | Shanghai Fengxuan Information Technology, 70 percent owned by Qihoo 360 |
| Killed by | removal from Chinese app stores, with no reason given |
~ what you could actually see ~
The technically interesting thing about Tuber is where the censorship sat. The Great Firewall works at the border, on traffic, by blocking and resetting connections, which is expensive and imprecise and produces the familiar experience of a page that half loads and then stalls. Tuber moved the filtering into the application layer, in the one place where it can be exact.
A proxy that reads the content can do things the border never could. It can serve you a real YouTube page with specific videos missing from it and no indication that anything was removed. There is no timeout to notice and no error to screenshot. For a government that is a strictly better instrument than a firewall, and the user has no way to measure what it removed.
~ who was allowed to call it good ~
On 9 October an editor at the Global Times, which is published under the People's Daily, posted in English that China had launched a browser reaching Facebook and Twitter without a VPN and that it was good for stability and a great step for China's opening up. That tweet is the strongest evidence anyone has about what Tuber was meant to be, because state-affiliated media does not promote a censorship circumvention tool to a foreign audience by accident.
Bloomberg's read was that an app like this could not have launched without official blessing, which makes the removal the puzzle rather than the launch. Fortune reported an industry theory pointing the other direction: Qihoo would have needed licenses from the foreign sites whose content it was reframing, and Google may have moved to cut it off. Nobody has confirmed either version. Qihoo 360 never commented.
~ a block that announces itself ~
Turkey blocks websites, and the mechanics here have always been loud about it. When YouTube went dark nationally between 2008 and 2010, what loaded instead of the video was a notice explaining that access had been blocked by a court decision, often with the deciding authority named on the page. Wikipedia spent nearly three years unreachable here, ending in January 2020. The censorship arrived as paperwork, printed on the screen where the video should have been.
Tuber made no such announcement. A search ran and the results came back simply shorter than they should have been, with no notice attached and no error to point at. That is the whole engineering advance here, and it is why the app is worth remembering for longer than it existed. A loud block teaches a population that it is being blocked. A quiet filter teaches it that it has seen everything.
~ leave a rose ~
an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.
@}-->-- ... roses left here
~ leave a wreath ~
a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.
paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.
» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe
other browsers: Erwise, Swing Browser, Timberwolf, DoDots
also died in the 2020s: Project Mariner, Replika (pre-2023 romantic era), Keen
~ leave a note ~
visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.