The Outline

» see theoutline.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the eulogy ~

the outline's peak years overlap with my mid-thirties tech-news consumption, but i mostly read it through screenshots on tech twitter rather than as a regular destination. the card-stack reading interface that the outline was built around did not really work on the desktop browsers i was using to read the verge and ars at the time, and i never installed it as a habit.

joshua topolsky launched the outline on december 5 2016 under a holding company called independent media. topolsky was coming off engadget and the verge, so the site arrived with a lot of design press and a lot of expectations. the visual identity was the entire pitch: every article showed up as a stack of cards you swiped through, sized for the phone first and adapted for desktop second. nobody had really committed to that kind of mobile-card layout in long-form journalism before.

the writing was real. the outline ran tech criticism, politics coverage, culture essays that did not read like anyone else's tech-culture site. for a while it felt like the natural successor to grantland in a different vertical. the problem was that the business never came together.

~ the dossier ~

~ how it landed ~

the outline was funded by venture capital from rre and advancit, with a may 2018 round bringing the total raised past five million dollars. that is a normal amount of money to raise for a media startup, which is itself the problem. media startups need either huge scale or a niche subscriber base, and the outline never had a clear shape of either one.

the card-stack design got admired more than it got used. on phones it worked. on desktop it felt like the site was making you do extra work. publishers who tried to copy the format mostly backed off within a year. the outline's design ended up as a moment in mid-2010s tech criticism rather than as a template anyone else picked up.

~ the unraveling ~

the layoffs started in june 2018 and continued in september of the same year, which is not a great sign two years into a venture-backed publication. by march 27 2019 the company had been sold to bryan goldberg's bustle digital group, with topolsky staying on to run it. that kind of sale is usually the start of a quiet shutdown, not the end of one.

the editorial output kept going through 2019 and into early 2020. the outline stayed sharper than most of the bustle network even after the sale. then the pandemic hit and digital-media revenue collapsed in a way nobody had budgeted for, and the math that had been not-quite-working got worse fast.

~ the day it died ~

on april 3 2020, executive editor leah finnegan posted that the entire editorial team had been laid off. the final article on the site had already gone up on march 20. there was no farewell editorial, no shutdown post explaining what had happened, just an empty queue and an archive that bustle agreed to keep online.

the outline is mostly remembered now as the canonical card-layout experiment that the rest of the web did not adopt, and as a covid casualty in a publication wave that included a lot of other media-startup deaths the same year. the writers scattered to substack and to other newsrooms. the card-stack interface went away with the brand.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »