The Messenger

» see themessenger.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obituary ~

the messenger never reached me. it was a us digital-news startup whose entire orbit was the washington-and-new-york political press cycle, the kind of site you would have read if your daily reading list already included axios and politico, which mine did not. by may 2023 when it launched i was forty and reading what i read for work, mostly bloomberg on edge ai funding rounds and the occasional ars technica piece.

finkelstein had owned the hill until 2021, when nexstar media bought it for around $130 million. the messenger was supposed to be the next play, a nonpartisan general-interest publication built fast at scale and funded with $50 million of seed from a list of finance and politics insiders. mark penn, victor ganzi from hearst, josh harris from apollo, james tisch, thomas peterffy. the staff target was 550 by end of year one and the revenue target was a hundred million for 2024.

the launch on may 15 2023 happened with about 150 reporters and editors already hired. dan wakeford from people came in as editor in chief on the entertainment side, marty kady from politico on politics, dan kauffman from the athletic on sports. the editorial direction was hard to read from the start, partly because of the nonpartisan claim and partly because the site immediately leaned on aggregation and clickbait headlines that did not look like the prestige newsroom the founding pitch had promised.

~ the case file ~

~ the climb ~

this part i saw from press coverage only. the early months ran hot. by july 2023 the messenger had pushed past 300 staff. offices in new york and washington, with a satellite west palm beach bureau for finkelstein himself. traffic spiked on a few aggregation pieces, the homepage looked like a 2014 huffpost reskin with bigger photos. inside the building the press write-ups were already grim. executives were leaving over clashes with richard beckman, the finkelstein-installed president whose mandate was scale-fast at any cost.

the revenue side never matched the hiring side. advertisers were not coming in at the rates the model required, partly because programmatic display had collapsed since the buzzfeed-era benchmarks the messenger was modeling against. by late 2023 internal forecasts had the company burning through the seed capital well before any breakeven path. finkelstein went out for additional funding in the fourth quarter and came back without a deal.

~ what really happened ~

the way the shutdown happened is the part most reporters covered. on january 31 2024 finkelstein sent a short email to staff that operations would end immediately. no severance and no continued health coverage. the publication had been unable to raise more capital. staff learned about it from press reports landing in their inbox at the same time as the internal email. the website went read-only within hours, then dark within a few days.

the warn act class action filed before the end of the week. federal law required 60 days notice or pay-in-lieu for a layoff of that scale, the messenger had given neither. the suit moved through 2024 with the unsecured creditors waiting on whatever was left of the seed capital. by mid-2024 the site's domain had stopped resolving entirely and the archive of about eight months of stories was effectively gone except for what the wayback machine had captured.

~ the long tail ~

what the messenger turned into is a case study people quote in business school columns now. the failure was not really editorial. the underlying problem was that the cost structure of a 300-person newsroom is incompatible with the cpm rates the open ad market still produces for general-interest news in 2023 or 2024. buzzfeed news had folded the year before for the same reason. the wave continued through 2024 and 2025 with rooster teeth, vice's bankruptcy, hellogiggles and kinja among the bigger names.

the finkelstein-specific part of the story is the unwillingness to break the plan when the numbers came in. the right move at the messenger by november 2023 was probably to cut headcount in half, restructure the site around a smaller and more focused vertical, try to extend the runway by two more quarters and re-pitch the investors. instead the spend continued until the bank account was almost empty and the shutdown happened with no orderly wind-down. the eight and a half month lifespan is the shortest of any well-funded us news startup in the modern era.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »