NotebookReview

» see notebookreview.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obit ~

The Internet Archive first crawled notebookreview.com in April 1999, and by that October the title tag read "Your guide to PC notebooks and laptops". The keyword list underneath it is a museum piece in itself: Sager, NEC, Compaq, used laptops, refurbished laptops, laptop memory. This was the era when a portable computer cost more than a used car and buying the wrong one was a two-year mistake, so a site that measured things and let owners argue about them had an obvious reason to exist.

It grew into a network rather than a single site. TechnologyGuide, Inc. ran NotebookReview alongside Brighthand for handhelds and phones, TabletPCReview, DigitalCameraReview and SpotStop, with DesktopReview later folded into the main site. On 26 April 2007 TechTarget bought substantially all of those assets for fifteen million dollars in cash, which its own quarterly filing explains as buying a way into the laptop and smartphone markets where it had nothing. TechTarget's actual business was selling leads to enterprise IT vendors, and a forum full of consumers comparing ThinkPad hinges was never going to fit that neatly.

On 22 January 2022 Charles Jefferies, a reviewer and moderator of long standing, posted the announcement: every TechnologyGuide site and forum would be going offline, effective 31 January. The wording he used for the staff was "small but dedicated volunteer staff", which is the sentence that tells you how the place had been kept alive for the previous decade. Nine days of notice for twenty-three years of threads.

If you typed a laptop model number into a search engine between roughly 2004 and 2014, you landed here. I was studying computer engineering through most of that window, in a country where a laptop was an import-priced object you researched for weeks before buying, and the research all ended in the same place: an owner's lounge thread four hundred posts deep where somebody had already opened the machine and photographed the thermal paste. Donanımhaber and frmtr did this in Turkish and did it well. NotebookReview did it for every model sold anywhere, with the signature block under each post listing the poster's exact hardware, which is a habit I recognize because I had the same one.

~ the rap sheet ~

~ the owner's lounge ~

The forum's organizing idea was a subforum per manufacturer and, inside that, a thread per model called an owner's lounge. You did not go there to decide what to buy. You went after you had bought, to find out whether the coil whine was normal and which BIOS version broke sleep. Threads ran for years and outlived the machines, picking up posts from people buying the thing secondhand in 2016 because it was now cheap.

That structure is also why the shutdown mattered more than the traffic numbers would suggest. Reviews age into nothing, while an owner's lounge for a discontinued laptop ends up holding the only written record of a specific manufacturing defect, kept by the owners it happened to.

~ who was actually running it ~

By the end the network was staffed by volunteers who moderated for free and wrote reviews for very little. TechTarget had spent the intervening years becoming a much larger enterprise media company and the consumer sites sat on the balance sheet as an acquisition from 2007 that no longer described anything the company did. The notice gave no reason beyond the decision itself.

Archive Team was told in time. A grab ran through the last week of January 2022 and the collection went into the Wayback Machine, with a dated archive.org item created on 25 January. The crawl logs are visible in the capture history: dozens of hits on the forum index inside single minutes on 20 and 30 January, which is what a rescue looks like from the outside. The last live capture of forum.notebookreview.com is from the morning of 31 January 2022.

~ what people did next ~

Some of the regulars tried to reconstitute the forum at a new address. That is the normal afterlife of a dead message board and it rarely takes, since what people were trying to carry across was twenty years of accumulated posts rather than a forum install. Today notebookreview.com and technologyguide.com both resolve, and both redirect to a TechnologyGuide section on Informa TechTarget's corporate site, where the name now functions as a content category.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »