IslamOnline

» see islamonline.net as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obituary ~

What ended IslamOnline was a server migration and a password change. That is the part an engineer cannot look away from. A newsroom of roughly 350 people had spent thirteen years building the largest religious reference site in Arabic, and when the argument finally came, all of its independence turned out to be resting on a single question: who holds the credentials. In March 2010 the answer came back, and it was not them.

The site was founded on 24 June 1997 under Yusuf al-Qaradawi, the Egyptian scholar who by then had a television program on Al Jazeera and an audience across the Arab world. The money and the legal ownership sat in Doha with a body called the Al-Balagh Cultural Society. The actual work sat in Cairo. Two editions ran side by side, Arabic and English, written for different readerships rather than translated from one another. Between 2000 and 2003 alone the operation published somewhere around 306,000 separate items, most of them in Arabic.

Before the dispute it was pulling about 120,000 visitors a day. That number sounds small in 2026 and was not small in 2010 for a site in Arabic, in a market where nobody with a serious budget had built anything comparable.

I never read it. My internet in 2010 was Turkish and English and pointed at other things entirely, and the questions IslamOnline existed to answer were answered locally in Turkey, in Turkish, by people who were not on it. So the reason this one is here is not that I lost something. It is that the mechanism is worth writing down.

~ the case file ~

~ what it actually was ~

The center of the site was a service called Ask the Scholar. You wrote in with a question and a named scholar answered it in public, permanently, in a searchable archive. There was a counterpart called Cyber Counselor doing the same for personal problems. Everything else on the site, the news desk and the family pages, hung off that core.

The editorial line was the reason it mattered and the reason it died. The Cairo desk wrote from a moderate and pluralist position, and by the late 2000s it was one of the few large religious sites on the Arabic web that people outside the region could point at as evidence that the category was not monolithic. That reputation belonged to the editors, not to the domain, which is a distinction nobody makes until the day it becomes load-bearing.

~ the fifteenth of march ~

By early 2010 the board in Doha wanted something more conservative. The editors say the flashpoint was a piece about Valentine's Day that the board rejected outright. Ask the Scholar and Cyber Counselor stopped publishing new material after February. Then the technical move: the site was transferred onto a smaller and slower server and the passwords were changed, so the newsroom in Cairo could no longer publish to its own front page.

The staff started a sit-in inside the offices on 15 March. On 31 March the board announced that every contract in Cairo was terminated. Around 12 million Egyptian pounds in severance had been promised and then withdrawn, and later agreed in writing anyway. More than 270 people were still waiting on it long afterward. Al-Qaradawi tried to mediate and Doha removed him as chairman of Al-Balagh shortly before he was due to fly to Cairo, which settled any remaining question about who was running what.

~ where the newsroom went ~

On 9 October 2010 the same editorial team put up OnIslam.net and started over with nothing but the people. Six years later most of that work had moved again, to aboutislam.net, which opened in January 2016. Today onislam.net answers with a parking lander and nothing else.

Meanwhile islamonline.net is fine. It loads and it publishes, and it has been doing both out of Qatar for sixteen years. If you only checked the address you would conclude that nothing ever happened here. That is the shape worth keeping: a publication is not a domain, and the thing that can be taken from you is not the part with the DNS record.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »