
InPhonic
» see inphonic.com as it lived, on the wayback machine
~ the obituary ~
David A. Steinberg had already run a cellphone business out of a Bethesda basement and built it to twelve stores and $22 million in sales, then broken it up. In 1999 he started InPhonic in Washington DC to do the same thing without the stores. The board he assembled was unusually heavy for a company selling handsets on the web: John Sculley of Pepsi and Apple, and Jack Kemp, who had run for vice president of the United States.
It worked. The company went public in November 2004 and raised $108.9 million, after an earlier attempt in 2002 had been pulled because the market was bad. By early 2006 it was claiming a third of the entire US market for third-party online phone sales, on 850,000 handsets moved in 2005 alone. By that June it put its running total at more than 2.5 million activations over three years. Revenue in 2006 was $320.5 million. Behind the scenes it also powered around 6,000 other companies' phone storefronts, and in April 2006 it became Amazon's first third-party wireless provider.
Almost nobody bought from a site called InPhonic. The company's own storefront was Wirefly, which had won a Forbes Best of the Web award in 2004, and the rest of the business ran under names like A1 Wireless, Liberty Wireless, Cellular Choices, FonCentral and Talking on Air. Seventeen brands, one warehouse operation in Largo, Maryland. If you bought a phone online in the United States in 2006 there was a fair chance you were buying from this company and had no idea.
This part of the internet never existed in Turkey at all. American phones were sold against two-year carrier contracts, which is what made it possible to advertise a handset at zero dollars, and Turkish buyers in 2006 walked into a shop and bought a phone for what a phone cost. The whole mechanism InPhonic was built on, the subsidy and the paperwork that released it, had no local equivalent to recognize.
~ the case file ~
| Born | 1999, Washington DC, founded by David A. Steinberg |
|---|---|
| Peak | $320.5 million revenue in 2006, 850,000 phones sold in 2005 |
| Killed | 8 November 2007, Chapter 11 in Delaware |
| Lifespan | 8 years |
| Made by | David A. Steinberg, with John Sculley and Jack Kemp on the board |
| Killed by | a credit agreement default, and a storefront whose prices needed an envelope |
~ the rebate ~
The business model had a catch in it, and the catch is why anyone still remembers the name. The advertised price depended on a mail-in rebate. You bought the phone at one number and got back to the lower number only by sending in documents, correctly, within a window, and having the claim accepted.
Federal regulators settled charges in April 2007 over how that worked. The allegations were that the company failed to supply the documents customers needed in order to claim, failed to send checks, did not adequately disclose the terms before purchase, misled some people about how many wireless bills had to be submitted, and misrepresented whether an incomplete application could be resubmitted. The remedy was an order to pay the customers who had applied and been refused. Before that, the District of Columbia attorney general had sued over the same practices, with a settlement reported in November 2006.
The Better Business Bureau covering Washington DC had the company at an unsatisfactory rating, with 126 unresolved consumer complaints processed in the 36 months to October 2007.
~ the creditors ~
InPhonic filed a voluntary Chapter 11 petition on 8 November 2007 in the US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware, with the cases jointly administered under number 07-11166. It listed about $120.9 million in assets against $179.4 million in debt. The stated causes were a default under a prepetition credit agreement and declining revenue from marketing that was not paying for itself, together with an inability to keep the popular handsets in stock.
The top ten creditors were MSN, Yahoo, Google, AOL and Verizon. That list is the business model written out as a liability: a company whose customers arrived through paid search and portal placement owed its biggest unpaid bills to the places the customers came from. Many of the rebate customers waiting on checks appeared on the filing too, as unsecured creditors. Nasdaq suspended the stock on 20 November and delisted it in December.
~ what outlived it ~
Versa Capital Management of Philadelphia bid $50 million for substantially all the assets and separately put up $25 million in debtor-in-possession financing to fund the case. The court approved the sale on 18 December 2007. In January 2008 Versa relaunched the operation out of Reston, Virginia as Simplexity, under CEO Andy Zeinfeld, and kept running Wirefly.
Simplexity filed its own Chapter 11, also in Delaware, in March 2014, and Wirefly stopped selling on 12 March. Walmart was approved that April to buy the Simplexity assets for around $10 million, with one carve-out: the wirefly.com domain was not included. New owners relaunched Wirefly in May 2014 as a plan comparison site, which is what it still is. The brand survived two bankruptcies by shedding the business twice.
~ leave a rose ~
an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.
@}-->-- ... roses left here
~ leave a wreath ~
a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.
paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.
» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe
other online services: 23andMe, ASCII Net, FinanceWorks, edocr
also died in the 2000s: CNET Newsburst, Alfaskop, Derive
~ leave a note ~
visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.