Grams

~ the goodbye ~

The other graves in the darknet section of this inventory are markets. This one is infrastructure, which is the only reason it interests me. I have never had a reason to open a Tor browser looking for a drug listing, but I have spent twenty years around the dull problem Grams was solving: a pile of separate catalogs with no common index is useless to anyone hunting for one specific thing in it.

It launched in April 2014, seven months after the FBI took down the original Silk Road. The markets had multiplied by then and none of them talked to each other, so a buyer who wanted a particular item had to register on each site separately and look. Grams crawled them and put the results behind one search box.

The presentation was the joke everybody remembers. The logo spelled the name out in the same primary colors Google uses, on a white page with nothing on it but a text field. Press coverage called it the Google of the dark web and the site did nothing to discourage that, because the imitation was the whole pitch, telling a very online audience what the product did without a word of explanation.

~ the chronicle ~

~ the index ~

Search was the front door and the rest of it was a small advertising business built on the same borrowed design. Gramwords arrived in May 2014, an auction for keywords that let a vendor buy placement against a search term, which is AdWords with the serial numbers filed off. TorAds followed in November 2014 as a banner network for onion sites and never really took.

The more genuinely useful piece was InfoDesk. Vendors worked under a pseudonym and a PGP key, and when a market disappeared their reputation went with it. InfoDesk let a vendor register an identity once and carry the reviews across markets, so a buyer could check that the seller on this week's site was the one from last week's.

~ the money side ~

None of the above paid for anything. The revenue came from Helix, released in June 2014 as a bitcoin tumbler wired directly into market payments. You sent coins in, the service mixed them with everyone else's and sent different coins out to the destination, taking a percentage. A lighter version called Helix Light ran through Flow on the clearnet.

The scale of it only became public years afterward. FinCEN found that Helix had moved more than $311 million in virtual currency during its three years of operation, and in October 2020 it issued a $60 million civil penalty against the operator, the first action the agency had ever taken against a mixer. At the time it was running, it looked like a checkbox on a payment form.

Being the recognized name in that business had a cost. The first characters of an onion address can be brute-forced, so fake Grams sites multiplied on link directories under addresses copying the same grams7e opening, and people who thought they were mixing coins were handing them to a stranger. In August 2017 the top Google result for how to mix bitcoins was one of the fakes.

~ the goodbye note ~

On 9 December 2017 the administrator posted a PGP-signed message to the site's own subreddit announcing that everything would be switched off on 16 December, with a week for users to withdraw whatever they were holding. The reasons given had nothing to do with police. Other mixers had taken the business, and bitcoin transaction fees in December 2017 were at the peak of the bubble, which meant a service charging a percentage of small transfers could not clear its own costs.

The line worth keeping is the one about stress. The operator wrote that the money was not worth the aggravation of maintaining the site, which is a sentence you could lift straight from a burned-out maintainer's farewell post on GitHub. It is doing exactly the same work here.

~ the arrest ~

Two years and two months after the site went quiet, on 6 February 2020, the FBI and the IRS arrested Larry Dean Harmon in Akron, Ohio and charged him with running both Grams and Helix. He pleaded guilty in August 2021 and forfeited 4,400 bitcoins. Sentencing came in November 2024 and he got three years.

So the shutdown notice was true and also incomplete. The site really did close because the tumbling margin had gone, not because anyone had knocked on a door. The door came later, and it came for the payments business rather than for the search engine. The part of Grams that made it famous was never the part that got anybody arrested.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »