FrontierVille

» see zynga.com/games/frontierville as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obituary ~

frontierville was the kind of thing american facebook users opened during work breaks. i was not that audience. by june 2010 i was a year out of university, doing computer engineering work in ankara, and my facebook account was mostly turkish friends from school who were not playing zynga games. the zynga catalog had a real footprint in turkey but it ran heaviest with farmville and texas holdem. frontierville never landed in turkey at the same level as those two. its american-frontier theming sat at a cultural distance that turkish facebook users mostly skipped past.

the game launched june 9, 2010 from zynga east, the baltimore studio that zynga had bought when it acquired brian reynolds's company in 2009. reynolds was the lead designer, with prior credits on civilization ii and rise of nations. the pitch for frontierville was that it would do what farmville did but with a stronger narrative spine. you would clear land, build a homestead, raise a family of pioneer settlers, expand the homestead, defend against bears and snakes, and slowly unlock more of the frontier map. instead of the farmville fixed-camera grid, frontierville had a slightly more cinematic look with hand-drawn art and a soundtrack that leaned hard into the western motif.

the launch numbers were the cleanest evidence that zynga's social-game formula worked at scale. five weeks in, the game was at twenty million monthly active users and six million daily active users. that ranked it second on facebook only to farmville itself, which zynga also owned. for the back half of 2010 frontierville was the case study every game studio cited when arguing that facebook social games were the future of the medium. the academy of interactive arts and sciences nominated it for social networking game of the year at the 14th annual interactive achievement awards.

~ the case file ~

~ the climb ~

the gameplay loop was straightforward. you would visit the homestead every few hours, harvest crops, chop trees, feed livestock, complete a quest, send energy to neighbors, and accumulate enough wood and coin to build the next building. every action consumed energy that refilled slowly over time. premium content like rare animals or faster builders could be bought with horseshoes, the in-game currency that converted to actual dollars at the cash register. this was the same economy zynga had built farmville on, with the difference that frontierville had story arcs that gave the daily visits more flavor.

brian reynolds talked publicly about wanting to bring strategy-game depth to the social-game template. the pioneer trail expansion in august 2011 was the clearest expression of that. the expansion was designed as an oregon-trail-style narrative journey, complete with named characters, river-crossing decision points, and rescue missions that required you to complete tasks before time-limited windows closed. the rebrand at that point folded the original frontierville frame inside the new pioneer trail wrapper. the daily homestead loop continued underneath, but the new content sat in front of it.

~ the slide ~

by 2012 the social-game category had peaked across facebook. average daily-active users on top zynga titles started declining as the platform shifted attention toward mobile-native games on ios and android. zynga's own pivot toward mobile released words with friends and draw something acquisitions that pulled engineering and design talent off the facebook flash titles. brian reynolds left zynga in 2013 for secret new world to work on a different mobile game. frontierville stopped getting major content updates around the same time.

the broader collapse of facebook flash gaming followed adobe's announcement that flash would be deprecated. by 2014 zynga was visibly winding down its facebook back catalog. titles that had been the proof points of social gaming in 2010 were being held in maintenance mode while the engineering side concentrated on the casino and word-game mobile properties.

~ the day it died ~

on february 4, 2015 zynga announced six classic facebook games would shut down by may. frontierville (the pioneer trail) was on the list, alongside petville, treasure isle, mafia wars 2, vampire wars, and one or two others. the sunset date was april 30, 2015. there was no migration path. players could not export their homesteads or save the pioneer family they had been building for five years. the game just stopped loading on that date and the url returned a sorry-message page.

what got buried with frontierville was the proof case for the entire social-game theory of 2010. for about two years the industry believed that the future of the medium was browser games on social networks with energy mechanics and microtransactions. frontierville was one of three or four titles that proved that theory could ship at scale. the theory itself turned out to be wrong on a longer time horizon. by the time the games died nobody was making case studies about them. the genre is essentially extinct in 2026 outside of casino-style apps that share the same monetization dna underneath. brian reynolds's name is on the pioneer trail's wikipedia entry and on civilization ii's wikipedia entry, and the second of those two will be read more often.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »