
First International Telecom
~ the last words ~
Turkish mobile history skips this chapter completely. GSM arrived early here, took the market whole, and left no gap for a cheap short range alternative to grow in, which is also roughly why PHS sold almost nowhere outside East Asia: by the time it was exportable, the markets it would have gone into were already spoken for. So this is a standard whose specifications I have read and whose handsets I have never once held, run by a company whose entire subscriber base fit inside the top third of a single island.
First International Telecom, 大眾電信 at home and FITEL abroad, started in April 1997 selling pagers. In February 2000 it took a construction permit for a 1900 MHz low power mobile system, in October the telecoms authority handed it the 0968 number prefix, and in May 2001 it launched the only PHS network Taiwan would ever have. The technology was Japanese and cheap by design. Base stations ran at half a watt, handsets at ten milliwatts, cells were a few hundred meters across, and the economics only worked where people were stacked densely enough that you could hang transmitters off lamp posts. Northern Taiwan qualified. Most of the rest of the country did not, and FITEL never seriously tried.
It grew fast anyway. Subscribers passed one million in September 2005, on two number prefixes, with handsets mostly built by Inventec Appliances and a shareholder register that ran from UTStarcom and UMC to a security firm and an insurance group. One detail mattered more than any of that and never changed: FITEL numbers were not portable. A subscriber who wanted to leave had to give up their phone number to do it, which held the base together for years and then, at the end, made the collapse into a logistics problem for the regulator.
~ the record ~
| Born | April 1997, as a pager company |
|---|---|
| Peak | over one million PHS subscribers, passed in September 2005 |
| Killed | 18 December 2014, bankruptcy declared by the Taipei District Court |
| Lifespan | 17 years, the last six of them in court-supervised reorganization |
| Made by | a shareholder list that included UTStarcom and UMC |
| Killed by | 3G and then 4G, against a standard whose cells were a few hundred meters wide |
~ eleven and a half hours ~
On 15 April 2007 the network fell over at half past twelve in the afternoon and did not come back fully until midnight. More than half a million subscribers could not make a call for eleven and a half hours, and the customer service line went down with it, so they could not complain either. It was the worst outage in the six years the PHS network had been running.
Then came the part that made it a scandal rather than an incident. FITEL's service contract paid compensation only when an outage ran past twelve continuous hours, and then only five percent of the monthly fee. The outage stopped thirty minutes short. On top of that, roughly eighty percent of PHS subscribers were on plans with no monthly fee at all, so five percent of nothing was what the contract entitled them to. The chairman of the Consumers' Foundation called the clause outrageous in public and the Executive Yuan's consumer protection officer agreed it needed review. Nothing came of it.
~ the healthiest phone in taiwan ~
FITEL's advertising leaned hard on the one genuine physical advantage PHS had, which was that a ten milliwatt handset radiates far less than a GSM phone. The campaigns put numbers on it. PHS radiation was advertised at about one hundredth of an ordinary mobile's, and the handsets were described as the only ones suitable for use in a hospital. The GSM operators were not amused. On 24 April 2008 the Fair Trade Commission ruled that the claims were false and misleading representations about the content and quality of a mobile service, then ordered the company to stop and fined it one million New Taiwan dollars.
The company adjusted the wording rather than the strategy. On 1 April 2009 the Fair Trade Commission met again over a line on FITEL's own website claiming that PHS was the only mobile phone system permitted in Japanese hospitals. It reached the same conclusion and issued the same one million dollar fine. The health angle was the last thing the network had that 3G did not, which is probably why it kept being worth a million dollars a year to say out loud.
~ counting down to zero stores ~
The company filed for reorganization at the Taipei District Court on 5 September 2008 and was granted it on 4 March 2009. The plan itself was approved on 7 December 2010. For a while after that it looked like a business. There was a roaming deal with Willcom in Japan in May 2010 and an international calling card with China Mobile that August, and the resident reorganizer told reporters in 2010 that PHS would be around for at least two more years and that new handsets were still coming.
The retail footprint tells the real story, because the Chinese Wikipedia entry tracks it store by store. Twelve company shops on 1 February 2012. Four by that November. Two on 1 June 2013, one in Taipei and one in Hsinchu. One on 1 April 2014. On 23 June 2014 the last shop closed and the only thing left serving customers was the call center. On 3 November 2014 the PHS website went into maintenance mode and stayed there. And on 9 May 2014, in between the last store closing and the website going dark, chairman Chang Min-yu called a reorganization press conference to announce a system upgrade that would connect to the 4G LTE networks launching later that year, and said the plan was still running and there was no intention of exiting the market.
~ what the court posted ~
Seven months after that press conference the Taipei District Court terminated the reorganization and declared the company bankrupt. The date is fixed by the court's own public notice, which states it plainly: the date of adjudication of bankruptcy was 18 December 2014, under the civil ruling in reorganization cases 5 and 6 of 2008. FITEL announced it to the public on 26 December, saying it would do what it could to keep the network running for its users, of whom there were still somewhere over six hundred thousand on the books and about a hundred thousand actually paying. Debts were around 5.7 billion New Taiwan dollars.
Three days later the chairman asked the Executive Yuan to put Chunghwa Telecom forward as bankruptcy administrator, essentially asking the national carrier to adopt the network. Chunghwa's acting spokesman pointed out that the two companies were already each other's creditor and debtor and that a neutral third party would be more appropriate, which is a polite way to decline. The court appointed an individual administrator instead, and called the first creditors' meeting for one in the afternoon on 29 April 2015 in a lecture hall at National Taipei University of Technology, which is the size of room a failure like this needs.
The network outlived the company by three months. On 11 March 2015 the National Communications Commission approved the application to terminate PHS service at the end of that month, and on 31 March the transmitters went quiet and the regulator took back the frequencies and the number blocks, helping the remaining subscribers port to one of the five 4G operators. The spectrum license had been due to run until April 2016. Nobody needed the extra year.
~ leave a rose ~
an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.
@}-->-- ... roses left here
~ leave a wreath ~
a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.
paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.
» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe
other connectivity: Oberthur Technologies, QuickCast (クイックキャスト), Periphonics Corporation, FrontlineSMS
also died in 2010-2014: HipGeo, Zipper Interactive, Is Anyone Up?
~ leave a note ~
visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.