Excel Communications

1988 - 2004
dead us
on 10 may 1996 a company that had existed for eight years became the youngest ever to list on the new york stock exchange, and it got there by having its customers recruit the next customers. kenny troutt was a billionaire by 1998 when teleglobe paid $3.5 billion for it. six years later the parent filed chapter 11, and the part of the business that was hardest to kill turned out to be the commission payments owed to the sales force.

~ the eulogy ~

Excel was founded in Dallas in 1988 by Kenny Troutt and Steve Smith, at the moment American telecom deregulation made it possible to buy long distance minutes wholesale and sell them retail without owning a wire. Dozens of companies did that. What made this one different was Smith's idea that the compensation structure of multi-level marketing, which until then had moved vitamins and cleaning products, would work better for a service than it ever had for a physical product.

He was right, and the reason is worth stating plainly. A box of supplements has to be shipped and then reordered. A long distance account is signed once and bills every month, which means a representative who signs up a neighbor collects on that neighbor's phone calls indefinitely. The sales force was not employed. It was paid in residuals on other people's phone bills, and it recruited more of itself.

The company reached a billion dollars in revenue nine years faster than Microsoft had. On 10 May 1996 it became the youngest company ever to join the New York Stock Exchange, trading as ECI. At some point in the late nineties it was the fifth largest long distance carrier in America, behind only AT&T, MCI, Sprint and WorldCom. Those are the four companies that owned the actual network, so fifth place was first place among the resellers. In June 1997 it bought Telco Communications Group in a deal reported at $1.2 billion, which got it off reselling other people's capacity.

~ the dossier ~

Born1988, Dallas, Texas
Peakfifth largest US long distance carrier, behind AT&T, MCI, Sprint and WorldCom
Killed1 November 2004, parent company Chapter 11
Lifespan16 years
Made byKenny Troutt and Steve Smith
Killed bythe end of long distance as a thing you paid separately for

~ the distance from here ~

None of this could have happened in Turkey and the reason is structural. Through the whole period Excel existed, Turkish telephony was a state monopoly, and there was no wholesale minute to resell and no competitive long distance account to switch anyone to. When I first went online in 1998 it was dial-up billed as metered local calls, and the ISPs I went through over the following years were TTNet and Superonline. The idea that a neighbor might knock on the door to sign you up for a different carrier would have made no sense to anyone in the building.

The American long distance bill is a vanished object in its own right. It was itemized by distance and time of day, and it was large enough that shopping around for it was worth somebody's afternoon. An entire industry of persuasion existed on top of a line item that no longer appears on anyone's bill.

~ what Teleglobe paid ~

In November 1998 Excel merged with Teleglobe, the Canadian carrier, in a deal valued at $3.5 billion. Kenny Troutt became a billionaire on it. He retired as chief executive on 20 September 1999 and was replaced by Christina Gold.

Teleglobe's largest shareholder, BCE, took full control in 2000, having already held 23 percent. In 2002 BCE terminated its relationship with the business, and the litigation over that abandonment ran for years. Excel was demoted to a subsidiary, then spun off to a private company, VarTec, which needed regulatory approval to take it back out of public hands and which carried on running the network marketing model afterwards.

~ the filing ~

On 1 November 2004 VarTec, by then Excel's parent, unexpectedly filed for Chapter 11 in the Dallas division of the US Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Texas, case 04-81694. One of the things the company sought in the proceedings was release from its contracts with the independent representatives, which would let it keep collecting from the installed customer base without paying the commissions those customers had been signed up to generate.

That is the structure failing at the exact point it had succeeded. The residual commission is what made the sales force work, and it is a perpetual liability against a revenue line that was shrinking every year as long distance stopped being a separate purchase. By then the representatives had organized a franchisee association to argue the point back.

~ afterwards ~

The Federal Communications Commission approved the transfer of the licenses to Comtel Telecom Assets in September 2005, and the company came out of bankruptcy on 12 June 2006 under new ownership, announcing a return to a lightly revised version of its old name as Excel Telecom. In March 2010 Matrix Business Technologies announced it would buy the customers and substantially all the assets of Comtel.

Kenny Troutt put the money into horses. He owns WinStar Farm in Versailles, Kentucky, 2,600 acres of thoroughbred operation, which bred and raced Justify to the thirteenth Triple Crown in 2018. Forbes had him at $1.7 billion in March 2025. The long distance company that paid for it has been gone for two decades, and excel.com is now a page offering the domain name for sale.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a wreath ~

a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.

paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.

» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

other connectivity: Oslonett, Dial-up Internet, TTNET, EZweb

also died in the 2000s: Silence, on Court!, AppForge, Libranet

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »