Discord Store

» see discord.com/store as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the last words ~

the discord store opened to a closed beta on august 9, 2018 and to everybody on october 11 of that year. the pitch had two halves. first, a curated storefront where discord would handpick games to sell directly through the chat client, with the explicit framing that discord wanted to be the indie-friendly alternative to steam and the new epic games store. second, a "first on discord" exclusivity program offering developers 90 days of exclusivity in exchange for a marketing push, and a bundled rotating-library of free games for anyone who paid for nitro, discord's premium subscription.

at the time, the store felt like a credible move. discord was already where pc gaming communities lived. ninety million people had accounts. the company had just raised at a $2 billion valuation and was visibly trying to monetize beyond t-shirts and emoji packs. nitro had been bumped from $4.99 to $9.99 monthly in part to fund the game-library benefit. the question was whether enough discord users would buy games inside discord instead of inside steam, which already held their friend graph and library plus all the reviews they would read before buying.

the answer turned out to be: not enough. on october 16, 2019 discord announced the store was closing. the official wording was that too few people were playing the free nitro games for the cost to make sense, and the company was redirecting its store ambitions toward a different model where any server admin could sell games through their own server's store channel. the rotating nitro game library got wound down on the same date. the storefront itself stopped accepting new purchases shortly after.

i was on discord by the time the store launched. by 2018 it was the chat client of choice for most pc gaming communities and for several open-source projects i followed. i never opened the store tab. steam was where my library was, and the friction of moving even one purchase to a different ecosystem with a different launcher and a different friend list was not worth whatever discount the store offered. that is roughly what discord found out at scale. existing pc-gaming behavior was sticky to steam, and being inside the chat app where everyone hung out was not enough leverage to break that stickiness for transactions.

~ the record ~

~ how it landed ~

the launch lineup was small but interesting. starbreeze's "system shock 2 enhanced edition," the new "spellforce 3" expansion, and a handful of indie titles got the first-on-discord exclusivity treatment. discord positioned itself as paying out 90 percent revenue share to developers, versus steam's standard 70 percent, and explicitly cited that as the reason developers should choose discord first. for a few weeks in late 2018 there was a real conversation in indie gaming press about whether discord could be the steam alternative that epic was also racing to become. by mid-2019 that conversation had quietly stopped happening because the sales numbers had not materialized.

~ the fall ~

two structural problems showed up early. nitro subscribers were getting free games but mostly not installing them, which meant the cost of licensing those games for the bundle was not being recouped through engagement or marketing value. second, the storefront itself was visited rarely. people opened discord to chat, to voice-call into a raid, to share a screenshot. they did not open discord to browse for new games. by the time you decided you wanted a game, you were already in steam. discord could not redirect that intent without offering either price advantages it could not sustain or social features steam did not have, and steam's friend graph and library lock were strong enough that the social-features pitch did not land.

~ what got buried with it ~

what got buried with the discord store was the broader idea that chat-and-community platforms could become game-distribution platforms. discord was the best-positioned candidate for that pivot. if it could not work for discord with ninety million pc gamers, it was not going to work for anyone with a smaller install base. epic kept pushing its own store with the exclusive-deals model and a war chest from fortnite, and that model worked at modest scale precisely because epic could pay for exclusivity in cash rather than relying on community routing. discord's later experiment of letting individual servers run shops within their own community channels never really lit up either, and by 2022 most of that infrastructure had been scaled back. by 2026 discord makes most of its money from nitro and server boosts, which is what the company had really been building toward all along.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »