DataLounge

» see datalounge.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the eulogy ~

In 2026 a thirty-one-year-old forum closed and gave as one of its reasons that search engines had stopped sending people to websites. I had never read DataLounge. The reason it put on the door applies to every site I ever did read.

It was made in May 1995 by Mediapolis, a New York interactive media company that three partners had started that January. The first version was a gay web portal in the shape everybody was building then, news and gossip with a directory of links attached, sitting alongside a dating site and a web guide run by the same people. When Out.com stopped operating in March 1997 its forums and its dating service came across, and that transplant is roughly where the portal stops being the point.

By 2000 the discussion side had swallowed the rest of it. Posting was anonymous by default and stayed that way for the site's whole life. Moderation came from a webmaster persona called Muriel. A voting mechanism sorted posts by whether other readers thought they were any good. Paying twelve to eighteen dollars a year removed the advertising, and from 2005 there were hours of the day when reading the busiest threads required being a subscriber, which is an unusual thing to sell and it worked for two decades.

It described itself, for most of those decades, as gay celebrity gossip and gay politics and pointless bitchery since 1995. That self-description is not modesty. A site that tells you exactly what it is on the masthead has already decided it does not need to be explained to anyone who wandered in.

~ the dossier ~

~ how it worked ~

Anonymity plus a reputation system is normally a recipe for a site that dies in eighteen months. DataLounge got thirty-one years out of it, and the reason seems to have been that the anonymity was total rather than partial. There were no accounts to build up, no follower counts, no profile to defend. What you had instead was the thread, and a readership that would take a post apart on the merits because there was no author standing behind it to consider.

The house style that produced was specific and self-perpetuating: unkind, extremely well read, allergic to sincerity, and fluent in a body of gay cultural reference that a new arrival either picked up or did not. People who found it unbearable were correct. People who stayed stayed for decades.

~ the rumor that got out ~

In February 2005 a claim appeared on DataLounge that the actress Marcia Cross was about to come out. It was not true. It went from an anonymous post on a forum into the mainstream press inside days and had to be denied publicly, and it is the moment the site is most often cited for by people who never went there.

It is a fair thing to hold against it and it also explains what the site was doing for thirty years. Celebrity sexuality speculation was the engine, and in 1995 that was one of very few places on the internet where the subject was discussed at all, by people it actually concerned, without a magazine's lawyers in the room. The same mechanism that made it worth reading in 1998 made it a liability in 2005. Nobody ever separated the two.

~ what closed it ~

The closing notice is short and it does not blame the audience. The platform and the software underneath it were very old, and keeping something that old secure and running had turned into an expensive piece of digital archaeology. There was no buyer waiting in the wings and no redesign planned. Muriel signed off as retired or possibly fired, who can say.

The other reason given is the one worth writing down. Search engines had shifted from directing traffic to websites toward harvesting what was on them, and the site had lost its connection to the wider ecosystem that had been feeding it, along with the posters that ecosystem used to deliver. A forum that ran three decades on incidental search arrivals is precisely the kind of thing that stops working when a search result answers the question instead of pointing at who answered it. Thirty-one years and better than thirty-six million posts, and the last line on the way out was an instruction to whoever left last to turn off the servers.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »