Classic Shell

» see classicshell.net as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obituary ~

Windows 8 shipped in october 2012 without a start menu. For about two years after that, helping somebody with their computer often meant explaining where their programs had gone and then installing a small free program written by one man in his spare time.

Classic Shell was older than the crisis it got famous for. It arrived on 29 november 2009, aimed at Windows 7 and at people who preferred the way Windows XP had handled the shell. It came in parts. Classic Start Menu gave you the old menu in several styles and Classic Explorer put a toolbar and a status bar back into the file manager. A third piece did the same tidying for Internet Explorer. All of it free, all of it written by Ivo Beltchev.

Then Windows 8 removed the start menu outright and Classic Shell stopped being a preference and became a repair. Downloads across SourceForge and FossHub reached close to forty million by the end of 2024, seven years after the last release. Microsoft put a start menu back in Windows 10, which should have ended the story and did not, because what came back was not the menu people had been asking for.

In the first days of december 2017 Beltchev posted that he was finished. "Sad news, everyone. After months of deliberation, I have decided to stop the development of Classic Shell." The reasons were ordinary and completely legible: no free time left for it, and a Windows 10 release cycle that shipped twice a year and broke the undocumented hooks he relied on to sit inside Explorer. Under both was a platform moving away from Win32 toward an application model that would not let a program do what his did.

I have no memory of installing this one, which is the honest answer for a utility that solved a problem on other people's desks. What I recognize is older than Windows 8. Going to find a small free program that fixes exactly one thing is a habit from my first years online in Turkey, when a 33.6k modem and a shareware site were how software arrived at all. Classic Shell is late in that line: one person against one problem, with no company behind it.

~ the case file ~

~ what windows 8 did ~

The start menu had been the way into a Windows machine since 1995. Windows 8 replaced it with a full screen of tiles designed for a touch surface, on an installed base that was overwhelmingly mouse and keyboard. The objection was not nostalgia. Offices in particular had a decade of training material and support scripts built around a menu that was no longer there.

Small utilities filled the gap within weeks. Classic Shell ended up on the most machines, partly because it cost nothing and partly because it did not try to reskin the rest of the system. It restored the menu and left the rest of Windows alone.

~ eight fun and exciting years ~

Beltchev's announcement reads as a document about maintenance more than about a start menu. He had shipped a program that reached inside Explorer through behavior Microsoft never documented, which made every Windows update a chance for it to break. For eight years he absorbed that himself, for free, for millions of installs. Version 4.3.1 was the last one.

He did not walk off quietly either. The source went out under the MIT license on SourceForge and GitHub, and the binaries stayed available for six months while the forums ran to the end of 2018. That is a more careful exit than most paid software gets.

~ the second life of the code ~

A fork appeared in june 2018 under the name Classic Start and was renamed Open Shell that september. It is still maintained and still doing the same job on Windows 11, where Microsoft moved the start menu again and put it in the middle of the screen. The MIT license is why that was possible. A closed abandonment would have left forty million installs holding a program that quietly rots as the operating system moves underneath it.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »