Aureal Vortex

» see aureal.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obituary ~

i was around the right age for this one. by 1999 i was fifteen and reading hardware reviews on every turkish pc enthusiast forum that would load over a 33.6k modem, donanimhaber mostly, sometimes the early frmtr crowd. the aureal vortex versus creative sound blaster live debate ran in those forums the way the 3dfx versus nvidia debate ran one tab over, with the same energy and the same broken benchmarks pasted into the same long signatures. i never owned a vortex card. they were imported and expensive in turkey, and the few audio shops in ankara that stocked anything beyond integrated codec chips stocked sound blaster. but the argument over which chip rendered helicopter blades more correctly inside half-life was part of the background radiation of the pc i was assembling on paper, anyway.

aureal semiconductor started in fremont, california, as the renamed successor to media vision after some bankruptcy-restructuring shuffle. the technical core came from crystal river engineering, a small lab that had been working on head-related transfer functions for nasa simulation work. aureal acquired crystal river in may 1996 and rolled the research into a consumer audio chip called the vortex, followed in 1998 by the vortex 2. the vortex 2 was the part that made the case. it could compute reflections off walls in real time and pan environmental audio around a stereo headphone field with a precision that creative's emu10k1 chip could not match.

the headline board was the diamond monster sound mx300, a card with the vortex 2 chip that pc gamer and tom's hardware repeatedly singled out as having the best 3d audio of its generation. for a window of about eighteen months in 1998 and 1999 it was the recommendation that hardware enthusiasts handed each other.

~ the case file ~

~ the climb ~

a3d, the api aureal shipped to game developers, was an open competitor to creative's eax. for a window around 1999 a lot of the headline pc games supported both. unreal tournament and half-life mods both shipped support across both apis. it was rare to see a sound api fight as contested as the graphics api fight of the same era between 3dfx glide and direct3d, but for one chip generation aureal pulled it off.

~ the slide ~

creative labs filed a patent-infringement suit against aureal on 5 march 1998. the suit targeted three patents related to 3d audio rendering. aureal counter-sued. the litigation ran for more than eighteen months across multiple courts. legal costs piled up on both sides, but aureal was the smaller company and absorbed them less easily.

in december 1999 a us district court ruled in aureal's favor on the central infringement claims. by then the company had spent something like fifteen million dollars defending the case. aureal had also missed a generation of consumer-product launches while leadership focused on the courtroom, and inventory of the vortex 2 was already aging in retail.

~ how it actually ended ~

aureal filed for chapter 11 in early 2000 and the proceedings ran through the summer. on 21 september 2000 creative labs bought aureal's patents and remaining assets out of bankruptcy for $32 million. the irony was loud at the time. creative had lost the lawsuit, then bought the company that won it for less than the lawsuit had cost both sides combined. with aureal's patents in hand creative had no significant competitor in the consumer 3d audio chip market for the rest of the decade.

~ what came after ~

a3d itself was quietly retired. creative folded the relevant patents into its own roadmap and kept eax as the dominant api. the broader 3d audio category effectively went dormant after 2001 because there was no longer any commercial pressure to invent a better one. by the mid-2000s onboard motherboard audio had eaten the discrete sound card category entirely, and even creative was in slow decline.

the aureal story still gets cited as a case where winning the lawsuit meant nothing because the time it took to win the lawsuit killed the company. for the small group of pc enthusiasts who actually owned a vortex 2 card it remains the best-sounding piece of dedicated audio hardware they ever installed. the rest of us learned about it from forum signatures and pcgamer roundups, then watched the company that built it disappear into the legal bills it had won.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »