AOL CDs

» see aol.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obit ~

between roughly 1993 and 2006, AOL mailed out over a billion free signup CDs to potential customers in the united states. the CDs contained the AOL software plus a promotional offer (usually a number of free hours of dial-up access if you signed up). the campaign was so widespread that for an entire decade you could not collect your mail in america without finding an AOL CD in it. they came inside magazines. they came as standalone direct mail. they were taped to cereal boxes. they were handed out at airports.

the cumulative distribution was somewhere around 1.2 billion CDs, according to AOL itself. that is more CDs than there are americans. the cost of producing and mailing them was significant (estimated at around 35 cents per CD when including everything), so the campaign cost AOL hundreds of millions of dollars per year at peak. they did it anyway because each successful signup was worth a lot more than the campaign cost.

this is a US-only memory. AOL CDs were not really a thing in turkey or europe in the same volume. but the cultural reference is so strong that anyone who reads tech writing in english knows what they were. the AOL CD is a specific piece of late-20th-century americana.

~ the rap sheet ~

~ what they actually were ~

each AOL CD contained the AOL software installer plus a small autorun program that would walk you through signup. the offer on the disc varied by year. early ones offered something like 5 free hours. later ones offered 50, then 500, then 1000 free hours. the inflation of the free-hours offer was a real campaign metric, with each cycle pushing the number higher.

once you put the CD in your computer, the installer would copy the AOL software to your hard drive, set up your modem dial-in number, and prompt you to create an account. the signup involved a credit card. you got the free hours but you would need to remember to cancel before they expired. AOL counted on a percentage of users not cancelling, paying for the regular service, and becoming long-term customers.

this conversion model worked for over a decade. AOL grew from a few hundred thousand subscribers in the early 1990s to around 27 million at peak in 2002. the CD campaign was not the only reason but it was a significant one.

~ the secondary uses ~

because there were so many AOL CDs, and they were free, and most americans did not actually want to use them, they ended up being used for everything else. coasters. frisbees. art project material. christmas tree ornaments. wind chimes (a real subgenre of craft project from the late 1990s). bird-deterrent reflectors hung in gardens.

there was also a recurring "send your AOL CDs back" campaign by various consumer activists and environmental groups. the argument was that AOL was generating significant electronic waste. one organized effort tried to collect a million AOL CDs and dump them at AOL headquarters as protest. the effort got media attention but i do not think they actually pulled off the dumping.

~ how it ended ~

broadband killed the AOL CD. by 2002 most urban american households had cable or DSL internet. those users did not need AOL's dial-up service. signing up for AOL with a CD in 2003 made less sense than signing up by going to a website. AOL's CD distribution scaled back through the early 2000s. by 2006 it was effectively over. they kept doing some smaller direct-mail campaigns for a few more years but the billion-CDs era was done.

AOL's overall decline was happening in parallel. their subscriber count peaked in 2002 and declined every year after. the CD campaign had been about acquiring new subscribers, but the underlying product was no longer competitive. broadband ISPs offered better service for similar money and did not require a CD.

~ what survived ~

the cultural reference. AOL CDs are now a shorthand for late-90s direct-mail marketing. they show up in 2000s movies as visual gags. articles about old internet culture mention them. anyone over 30 in the US has a memory of a stack of them somewhere in a desk drawer.

the case study in CAC (customer acquisition cost). AOL was spending hundreds of millions of dollars per year to acquire customers via CD distribution. the lifetime value of a customer made it worth it. the math was real. modern marketing budgets in tech are still trying to find equivalents to that math, just usually with digital ads instead of physical mail.

the e-waste. a billion CDs is a lot of plastic. most of those CDs are now in landfills. some are still floating around as art-project supplies. a small percentage have been recycled. AOL's environmental footprint from this campaign is one of the more concrete examples of how a marketing decision can have material consequences.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »