Yahoo! Auctions

» see auctions.yahoo.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obit ~

yahoo auctions launched on september 14, 1998, just over three years after ebay had been founded. yahoo's pitch was simple: listing items would be free for sellers, and the company's revenue would come entirely from advertising. that worked well for yahoo's books in 1999 because the dot-com ad market was effectively a bottomless well at the time. it also worked well for sellers, who could test cheaper inventory on yahoo without paying ebay's listing fees first.

the actual problem was that auctions are a network-effect product. the site with the most buyers attracts the most sellers, which attracts more buyers. ebay had a four-year head start and a lot of sellers who already had positive feedback histories on the platform. yahoo's free-listing pitch could pull listings, but it could not pull the buyer concentration where it actually counted. by 2001 the gap between the two sites had widened, and yahoo had quietly added listing fees to try to clean up the cheap-spam problem that free listings had created.

yahoo auctions never had a turkish version. it was a us product with localized variants across canada, the uk, australia, singapore, hong kong, taiwan, plus a few other regional markets. turkey's online auction window opened separately when gittigidiyor launched in 2001 and ran on its own before ebay bought it in 2011, then eventually sold it to local owners. so my mental image of "auction site that died" is the gittigidiyor wind-down rather than the yahoo one. the yahoo north american site went dark four years before i would have heard the word ebay used in turkish casually.

~ the rap sheet ~

~ how it landed ~

yahoo entered auctions late but with the strongest brand on the english-speaking web in 1998. the home page got tens of millions of daily visits, and yahoo could move users into auctions through the same nav bar that already pushed mail and messenger. for a few months in 1999 it looked like that distribution advantage might be enough on its own. yahoo also had no listing fees, which made it attractive to low-margin sellers and casual hobbyists who would have hesitated to pay ebay's percentage. listings climbed fast through the next year.

~ the cracks ~

the network-effect problem caught up by 2001. ebay's seller feedback database had become a de facto trust system that yahoo could not replicate inside its own auctions. you could list the same antique camera on both sites, but the ebay listing would get more bids because more buyers were watching ebay listings. when yahoo introduced listing fees in 2001 to cut spam, a lot of casual sellers stopped relisting. the dot-com ad market also collapsed that year, which made yahoo's "monetize through ads" plan less reliable than it had looked in 1999.

~ what got buried with it ~

the june 2007 shutdown only affected the us and canadian sites. the international yahoo auctions properties closed at staggered intervals over the next thirteen years. the uk site went first in 2002. hong kong stayed open all the way until 2020. only the japanese version is still operational in 2026 under the yahoo japan brand, run with softbank since 1999, and that one has its own decade of cultural meaning attached, comparable to mercari's place in the late-2010s japanese internet. what yahoo north america lost in june 2007 was a footnote rather than a death. ebay had already won the us by 2003. the 2007 announcement was yahoo finally turning off the lights on a service that had stopped mattering several years earlier.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »