Spinrilla

» see spinrilla.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the eulogy ~

The mixtape was never a legal object. For thirty years it was how rap got distributed outside the label system: an artist records over somebody else's beat, and the thing circulates as a gift that everyone understands is also a business card. Cassettes became CDs sold out of trunks, and CDs became websites. Spinrilla was one of the last big websites.

Jeffery Dylan Copeland started it in Atlanta in early 2013 after leaving Georgia State. The pitch was the discovery gap: an app where unsigned and emerging hip-hop artists could put out a full tape and have it heard, without a label and without a distributor. It worked far better than a one-man project has any right to. By the time the lawsuit landed, Spinrilla had around 19 million registered users, roughly 1.5 million of them active every day, and about 1.4 million tracks. The Android app alone passed ten million downloads.

Crucially, it was not open. Only about 14,000 accounts had upload rights, which Copeland's side treated as evidence of a curated platform rather than a dumping ground. The labels treated the same number as evidence that he knew exactly who was putting the files up.

~ the dossier ~

~ how it landed ~

Mixtape sites occupied a strange position. Labels knew their artists used them and broke new records on them, while the same labels' legal departments were building a case against them. Spinrilla's defense leaned on that contradiction and on the DMCA safe harbor, the rule that says a host is not liable for what its users upload as long as it takes material down when told.

In February 2017 the RIAA-backed labels filed in the Northern District of Georgia. The complaint eventually settled on 4,082 copyrighted recordings that had been streamed at least once through the service, by artists running from Bob Marley to Beyoncé. At statutory maximums the exposure was reported at around $600 million.

~ the fifty million ~

The case turned in December 2020, when Judge Amy Totenberg found Spinrilla directly liable for infringement and held that the DMCA safe harbor did not cover it. That ruling is the whole story. Once the shield is gone, a host with 1.4 million files on it is not negotiating over whether it owes money, only over how much.

The answer came on 3 May 2023 as a consent judgment: $50 million, stated as inclusive of any recoverable costs and attorneys' fees. The injunction went further than the money. Copeland was permanently forbidden from operating Spinrilla or any other substantively similar website or application, anywhere in the world. Not a fine, a professional disqualification.

~ the day it died ~

He had five days from notice. The site and the apps went off on 8 May 2023, and spinrilla.com was transferred to the plaintiffs. Type it today and you land on WhyMusicMatters, the industry's own page about licensed services, which is a kind of trophy mounting.

Atlanta rap reached me the way it reached most of the world, through tracks that had already been filtered by somebody else, years after the tapes they came off had stopped circulating. The mixtape economy itself, the part Spinrilla actually ran, was a local distribution system I only ever saw the output of. What the shutdown took offline was the underneath: ten years of tapes by artists who never signed anywhere, hosted in one place, with no export and no mirror.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »