Real Alternative

» see codecguide.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the last words ~

The software never broke. It was taken down by a person who will not say why, and for fifteen years that person has been deleting the question wherever it gets asked.

Real Alternative did one thing. RealNetworks' formats,.rm and the variable-bitrate.rmvb that came later, sat under a large share of the video anybody downloaded in the mid-2000s, and playing them officially meant installing RealPlayer. RealPlayer wanted an account and left things running after you closed the window. The alternative was about five megabytes: the RealMedia codecs and a DirectShow splitter, packed with a copy of Media Player Classic and a browser plugin. You installed it once and then the files opened when you double-clicked them.

There is no reliable first-release date. The oldest capture of its download page is 4 April 2004, by which point version 1.22 was current with 1.20 and 1.11 still listed underneath it, so the project was already a year or more old. The last build was 2.0.2 in February 2010. Its sibling, QuickTime Alternative, did the same job for Apple's.mov files and shipped the same way, out of the same hands.

This is one I was on the right side of. By the middle of the 2000s a video that reached a Turkish machine had usually been squeezed into.rmvb by somebody optimizing for a slow line, because the format held a watchable picture in a file small enough to move overnight. So you had a file and no way to open it, and the choice was between installing a media company's entire client or installing five megabytes that solved the actual problem. Everyone I knew picked the five megabytes. Nobody thought of it as software. It was something you did once on a fresh Windows install, somewhere between the drivers and the archiver.

~ the record ~

~ what an alternative was ~

The word in the name was precise. These packs were not reimplementations of anything. They contained the actual codec binaries from the official distribution, lifted out of the installer and repacked without the client wrapped around them. That is why they worked perfectly, and it is also why they were always standing on soft ground.

The same author is behind the K-Lite Codec Pack, which is still shipping updates in 2026 and does the same trick for formats whose owners were not watching. K-Lite survived. The two Alternatives were the parts of the project that had a legal department attached to the other end.

~ the deleted threads ~

On 15 July 2010 Real Alternative and QuickTime Alternative came off the site. On 25 July the Lite builds followed. The stated reason was a decision to stop pointing people at proprietary software and encourage open-source players instead, which reads as an explanation until you see what came with it. Posts on the Codec Guide forum that mention the two packs get edited or removed, and people who keep asking get banned.

You do not moderate that hard over a change of principle. The obvious reading is a letter from somebody's lawyer with a condition attached about not discussing the letter, and the moderation policy is the shape that condition left behind. Both packs are still sitting on mirror sites, frozen at their 2010 versions, which makes for an odd afterlife. The software is not gone. Only the explanation was ever actually removed.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »