Punch

1841 - 2002
dead europe
twenty five pounds of capital in 1841 bought a weekly that handed english the word cartoon, and then spent its last half century being told it was not as funny as it used to be. united newspapers closed it on 8 april 1992 with circulation under 40,000. mohamed al fayed bought the name back in 1996, put sixteen million pounds through it, and gave up on 29 may 2002 with fewer than 6,000 subscribers left on the list.

~ the eulogy ~

Punch was founded on 17 July 1841 by Henry Mayhew and the wood engraver Ebenezer Landells, on an investment of twenty five pounds. The subtitle, The London Charivari, pointed at Charles Philipon's French satirical paper. The name came from the glove puppet of Punch and Judy, and partly from an office joke about the co-editor Mark Lemon: that punch is nothing without lemon. The money ran out inside eighteen months and in December 1842 the magazine was sold to Bradbury and Evans, printers who also published Dickens.

In 1843 the Houses of Parliament were being decorated with murals, and the full size preparatory drawings went on public display under the Italian word for them, cartone. Punch printed its own joke versions and called them cartoons. That is where the modern meaning of the word comes from. Most magazines leave behind a format or a rival; this one left a common noun. John Tenniel drew for it from 1850 and was chief cartoonist from 1864 to 1901, and the best known single image of Victorian political satire, Bismarck walking off the Kaiser's ship under the caption Dropping the Pilot, is his.

Circulation broke 100,000 around 1910 and peaked in 1947 and 1948 somewhere between 175,000 and 184,000. Everything after that was a slope. Malcolm Muggeridge, who edited it from 1953 to 1957, wrote in his diary that the issues before he arrived were depressing and feeble, and later said there was no occupation more miserable than trying to make the English laugh. By 1992 the weekly sale was under 40,000 and the editor, David Thomas, was blaming the growth of the Sunday papers as much as anything else. He told the Christian Science Monitor that there was simply too much to read in them, and that a lot of the humor had moved to television.

United Newspapers closed it on 8 April 1992, at 150 years old. That looked final.

~ the dossier ~

Born17 July 1841 in London, on 25 pounds of capital
Peak175,000 to 184,000 copies a week in 1947 and 1948
Killed29 May 2002, announced by Mohamed Al Fayed
Lifespan161 years across two runs
Made byHenry Mayhew and Ebenezer Landells, later Bradbury and Evans
Killed byfat Sunday papers, then a revival nobody bought

~ the yuppie turn ~

The thing that actually killed the first run was an attempt to save it. In 1988 Punch was losing a million pounds a year and, as the Monitor put it, was more likely to be found in a dentist's waiting room than on a subscriber's coffee table. United Newspapers eased out Alan Coren after a decade in the chair and gave the job to Thomas, who was 33, with instructions to find younger readers.

Keith Waterhouse, who had written for the magazine for thirty years and left when Coren did, gave the verdict afterward: they lost the audience they had and failed to acquire a new one. He thought chasing the yuppie market while the over 55s had all the money was plain stupid. Ian Hislop, running Private Eye at a readership of 200,000, said Punch had lost its way long before. Thomas did not really disagree with the diagnosis, only with the cure. The current style of popular humor, he said, was rough and ready, crude and libelous, and they could not go down that road.

~ the second death ~

Mohamed Al Fayed relaunched Punch in early 1996. The new one dropped Mr Punch from the covers in favor of a photograph of a boxing glove, so that the name would read as a blow rather than a puppet. It never made money. On the evening of 29 May 2002 Al Fayed announced that it was over, and the Guardian carried it the next morning under the headline 161 years on, Punch is dealt knock-out blow.

The numbers in that piece are brutal for a title of this size: sixteen million pounds of his own money gone in six years, subscriptions down to fewer than 6,000, each edition costing more than forty thousand pounds to produce. His statement had the shape of a man who knew the arithmetic had beaten him. He had done everything in his power to keep it alive by pumping in cash, he said, but as a businessman sometimes the head has to triumph over the heart. Of the twelve people on staff, eight were made redundant and four were kept on to run the archive.

~ what is still at the address ~

Those four are the reason punch.co.uk resolves today. The site is a print shop and a licensing desk sitting on a library of half a million cartoons, with a history page and a timeline, plus a page about the Punch table, the deal dining table Bradbury and Evans bought in the 1840s and let the staff carve their initials into. Only six outsiders were ever invited to cut into it. Mark Twain turned the invitation down on the grounds that Thackeray's initials were already there and he was not going to follow that.

Punch died the first time when I was eight and the second time when I was eighteen, and Turkey has a weekly humor press of its own that has never had to compete with a Sunday supplement. The transferable part is the first death, not the second: a 150 year old title that was still being read, just not by enough people, and a rescue plan that went looking for an audience that was never going to arrive.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a wreath ~

a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.

paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.

» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

other phenomena: Bert is Evil, Dancing Baby, Psychic Friends Network, The Listserve

also died in the 2000s: Street Fighter Online: Mouse Generation, Blaxxun Contact, Socialite Rank

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »