Phanfare

» see phanfare.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the goodbye ~

phanfare was the kind of thing american prosumer photographers used. i was not in that demographic. it launched in november 2004, built by andrew erlichson and mark heinrich in new jersey, and the entire pitch was a paid-only photo and video archive that did not lose your originals when the company changed strategy. there was no free tier, which in the flickr-and-picasa era was the whole point.

the technical move was running storage on amazon s3 from early on, which kept the unit economics workable for a subscription service while everyone else was burning money on free uploads. the consumer software included a desktop organizer called phanfare photo plus an iphone app called phanfare photon. the web gallery supported jpeg files alongside psd, plus avi quicktime wmv mpeg-2 for video. it served the kind of user who took a serious camera on family trips and wanted the negatives backed up for decades, not the kind who threw phone snapshots into facebook.

carbonite acquired phanfare on 6 june 2011 for an undisclosed sum, when carbonite was still the consumer online backup brand on us television ads. carbonite ran phanfare as a premium photo product alongside its main backup service for six years. on 28 may 2017 carbonite shut down phanfare after deciding to refocus on enterprise data protection. paying subscribers were given a window to download their archives.

~ the chronicle ~

~ the prosumer pitch ~

the cultural distance was sharp. by 2008 the photo-sharing tier was free and ad-supported on flickr or picasa web albums, social and free on facebook, mobile-first and free on instagram from 2010. phanfare was the opposite of all that. it cost ten dollars a month or one hundred a year, it had no public discovery features worth using, and it actively avoided the social dynamic that defined the rest of the category.

what it sold instead was retention. carbonite did not compete on price or virality. it competed on the promise that a wedding photographer's raw archive would still be there in 2025, in the original file format, retrievable by the original owner. the customers who valued that paid for it. the customers who did not went to flickr until yahoo wrecked the brand, then to google photos when it launched in 2015.

~ the postmortem ~

carbonite spent the 2014-2017 window moving its center of gravity toward enterprise backup. its acquisition of mozy from emc in 2018 cemented that pivot. the consumer-facing photo product no longer matched the company shape. the may 2017 phanfare shutdown was a small piece of a broader trim of carbonite's consumer surface, and most of the press coverage at the time was about the larger carbonite strategy rather than phanfare itself.

subscribers got download links and an export window. some of them moved to smugmug, which by 2017 had become the surviving us-coded paid photo service in roughly the same shape phanfare had been. carbonite itself was acquired by opentext in 2019 for $1.42 billion, finishing the transition from consumer brand to enterprise backup subsidiary.

~ what remains ~

phanfare left behind a quiet proof that the paid-archival photo model could work for thirteen years if you had a defensible niche. it did not survive the post-instagram phone-photo era because the consumer math against free was not winnable, but the survival pattern it carved is what smugmug runs in 2026. andrew erlichson went on to a teaching role at duke and then to roles in cloud infrastructure. the back catalogue of family photos that phanfare archived is mostly on user hard drives now, exported during the 2017 wind-down, and the brand is one of the cleanest small-business deaths in the 2010s us photo category.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »