Paddle8

2011 - 2020
dead us
forty four million dollars of venture money went into an online auction house that sold other people's art and ran other people's charity lots. in march 2020 a film co-op sued over a november benefit auction whose proceeds had never arrived, and a week later paddle8 was in chapter 11 telling everyone it was not shuttering. a court-appointed trustee liquidated it anyway. justin bieber's name is on the creditor list for just over seventy three thousand dollars.

~ the eulogy ~

Paddle8 lived in a price band I have never transacted in and do not expect to. Its whole pitch was the middle of the art market, the ten thousand to a hundred thousand dollar range that Sotheby's found too small to bother with and a local gallery found too big to move quickly. Everything about it, including how it died, belongs to a world where a painting is a liquid asset.

It was founded in May 2011 in New York. Alexander Gilkes had been an LVMH executive and then chief auctioneer at Phillips, and he started it with Aditya Julka, a Harvard Baker Scholar, and Osman Khan, a banker out of Goldman Sachs. The art world turned up behind it fast. Damien Hirst put money in, so did Jay Jopling of White Cube, and later rounds pulled in David Zwirner and Stavros Niarchos.

The money came in three waves: four million in a 2012 Series A led by Founder Collective and Mousse Partners, six million more in June 2013, then thirty four million in a Series C in October 2015 that took the total to forty four. In 2014 it reported sales above 35.8 million dollars, up 146 percent on the year.

~ the dossier ~

BornMay 2011 in New York, from a former Phillips auctioneer and two partners
Peakmore than $35.8 million of sales in 2014, up 146 percent
Killed15 March 2020, Chapter 11 in the Southern District of New York
Lifespan8 years, 10 months
Made byAlexander Gilkes with Aditya Julka and Osman Khan
Killed bycharity auction money that never reached the charities

~ the charity machine ~

Benefit auctions were the less visible half of the business and the half that mattered. Paddle8 ran sales for more than three hundred nonprofits and claimed a community of half a million collectors. By January 2015 it said it had presented over five hundred benefit auctions carrying more than 500 million dollars in bids, and that it had raised over 33 million dollars for nonprofit organizations.

Charity auctions bring something a startup cannot buy, which is the assumption that you are trustworthy. Foundations and artists hand you work for free because the proceeds are going somewhere good. The platform holds the money in between, and that gap is where this one ends up.

~ the unraveling ~

A Berlin merger came next. Auctionata took it in during May 2016, with Thomas Hesse running the combined company from September. When the German side filed for insolvency at the start of 2017, Paddle8 was separated back out and left to carry on alone. In December 2017 a Swiss investor syndicate took over the holding company and installed Izabela Depczyk as interim chief executive. In 2018 it went to Native. In August 2019 the Facebank group became its largest shareholder, and that November Valentine Uhovski was named chief executive.

Four ownership changes and at least three chief executives in under four years, on a business whose only real asset was being trusted with other people's money.

~ the november auction ~

In November 2019 Paddle8 ran a benefit auction for the New American Cinema Group, the nonprofit behind the Film-Makers' Cooperative, with donated work from artists including Kiki Smith and Jonas Mekas. The money never came. On 10 March 2020 the co-op sued, alleging the proceeds had been misappropriated. Five days later, on 15 March, Paddle8 filed for Chapter 11 in the Southern District of New York.

The company's public line was that this was a defensive move: Chapter 11 would "protect the company and its assets against aggressive legal maneuvering", and "we are not shuttering the business". It was shuttered. The chief executive and the entire board resigned and the court appointed an independent trustee, who liquidated the company and sold the remaining intellectual property during the proceeding. Creditors later sued Uhovski personally for a million dollars.

The creditor list named pop stars next to small foundations. Justin Bieber and his wife were owed just over 73,000 dollars, and Jay-Z's Shawn Carter Foundation around 65,000 from that November sale. The Rema Hort Mann Foundation was on it too. Today paddle8.com serves 114 bytes.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a wreath ~

a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.

paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.

» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

other online services: Baumarkt Direkt, Microsoft DreamSpark / Imagine, Google Friend Connect, honestbee

also died in the 2020s: Socratic, Ask.fm, Earbits

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »