Nokia Money

» see nokia.com/money as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the goodbye ~

nokia money was a mobile-money service nokia launched in india in august 2009. the technology came from obopay, a mountain view startup nokia had backed as lead investor in a $70 million round earlier that year. the pitch was branchless banking for feature-phone users in rural india. a nokia phone plus a nearby retailer agent equaled the ability to deposit cash, pay a utility bill, send money to a relative in another city, or receive a wage payment, all through sms and simple menu flows without ever visiting a bank branch.

the pilot ran with yes bank in mumbai starting february 2010. union bank of india came on as a wider partner by 2011. nokia trained phone-shop clerks in small towns as banking agents. by late 2011 the service was nationally available across india, with around 1.2 million users, and had been described in industry press as one of the more serious moves by a handset vendor into m-pesa's territory. m-pesa itself had launched in kenya in 2007 through safaricom and was the model the whole category was chasing.

then stephen elop's february 2011 restructure of nokia caught up with the payments unit. elop's job was to shrink nokia back to handsets and location services, drop symbian, adopt windows phone, and stop funding the diversification bets from the ollila and kallasvuo years. nokia announced on 12 march 2012 that the mobile-financial-services business was "not core to nokia" and that the india service would wind down. a company spokesperson said the pilot had been informative but the strategic fit was not there.

i was on a nokia n82 in ankara at some point in this window before switching to android around 2011, and nokia's india strategy did not touch me directly. the money service was an india-only product with no turkish equivalent from nokia. what it did rhyme with, from turkey, was the ttnet-postpaid-bill-payment-at-the-corner-shop pattern that already existed here through bkm ekspres and later ininal. the phone-shop-as-bank was a different flavor of the same idea, and the interesting thing was that in india it had a real user base before nokia decided to shut it.

~ the chronicle ~

~ the model ~

mobile money in emerging markets solves a specific problem: physical bank branches do not reach the last mile, but mobile phones do. m-pesa proved in kenya that if you turned every airtime reseller into a cash-in/cash-out point and let sms be the transfer rail, you could bank tens of millions of people in a few years. the nokia bet was that the handset vendor was better positioned than the operator to run this, because handset penetration was already there and phones were more trusted than the operator brand in a lot of markets. the counter-argument was that operators controlled the sms channel, the billing relationship and the retail network, and were harder to unseat once they moved on the same idea. m-pesa validated the operator side of the argument.

~ how it ended ~

the shutdown was quick. nokia announced the exit on 12 march 2012 and gave a wind-down period for existing users. yes bank and union bank of india retained the banking relationships but had to find new mobile rails. obopay carried on independently in india (it later got a wallet license from the reserve bank of india in december 2017) and pivoted to b2b white-label payments. nokia itself was already in freefall on the handset side, with the microsoft acquisition of the devices unit coming in september 2013. the money service was a rounding error in the balance-sheet story of nokia's collapse.

~ the tail ~

india's mobile money story eventually happened without nokia. paytm launched wallet in 2014. the united payments interface (upi) rail went live in 2016 and made real-time bank-to-bank transfer instant and free at the point of use. by 2020 the entire indian retail-payments ecosystem was upi-native and the branchless-banking-through-retailer-agents model that nokia money had been running looked pre-historic. the interesting counterfactual is not whether nokia could have kept the service going, but whether elop-era nokia was ever going to fund a five-year emerging-markets bet against operators and government payments infrastructure. the answer is no. the shutdown was overdetermined the day elop wrote the burning-platforms memo.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »