Munchery

» see munchery.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obit ~

i missed munchery. anyway, it was a san francisco bay product, the on-demand chef-meal layer never reached turkey at all. for some reason, the closest analog in ankara or istanbul through the 2010s was either yemeksepeti or getir's earlier grocery-delivery wave, both built on a different model. honestly, the chilled-meal reheat layer munchery sold was a pure us-coastal city product, dependent on dense apartment delivery routes and on a customer who would actually reheat a sealed plastic tray for dinner (close enough).

this part is mostly told from techcrunch and the san francisco chronicle, by then. tri tran and conrad chu had founded munchery in 2010 in san francisco after leaving vmware and tibco respectively. for whatever reason, the early concept was a small cohort of staff chefs running a centralized commissary, with a rotating daily menu of around ten entrees. either way, the order cutoff was 6 pm for same-day delivery, the chilled meals arrived between 5 and 9 pm in a clear plastic tray with reheat instructions on the lid.

the venture money started in 2012. anyway, sherpa ventures led a four million dollar round, menlo ventures led a twenty-eight million dollar round in 2014, the eighty-seven million dollar series c landed in may 2015 with e.ventures pushing the valuation toward three hundred million. for some reason, the company expanded fast on the back of that, opening new york in late '14, los angeles in early '15, seattle in late '15. by then, the four-metro footprint was the peak operational state munchery ever reached.

by 2017 the retrenchment had started, anyway, munchery shut new york in march '17 and los angeles a few months later, citing operational losses on the routes. for whatever reason, the founders both left the company in late '17, with james beriker brought in as ceo to try to right the ship. either way, the unit economics never bent toward profit. an anonymous former chef quoted in business insider in '19 called the company "a house of cards" and described huge food-waste rates from over-prepped daily menus.

the shutdown notice landed by email on january 21 '19. honestly, no warning, no wind-down period, no severance for most of the two hundred and fifty-seven staff. by then, the bankruptcy filing showed assets of one to ten million against thirty-four and a half million in liabilities, of which twenty-eight and a half million was secured debt. for whatever reason, the founders did not comment publicly, the press scrambled for the post-mortem, and the munchery brand sat dormant until rolliyo inc. relaunched it in october 2020 as a recipe-only site with affiliate links (or roughly).

~ the rap sheet ~

~ how it landed ~

the early munchery pitch in 2011 and '12 was an attempt to do for prepared meals what blue apron was about to do for raw ingredient kits, on a same-day basis. for some reason, the chilled-meal-with-reheat model was meant to thread a gap between hot delivery, which had logistics overhead, and frozen meals, which had freezer-aisle competition. either way, the early san francisco user base liked the rotating chef-driven menus and the local-sourcing claims, those were the parts of the pitch that did real work for the brand (close enough).

this part you had to be on the us coasts for, and i was not. anyway, the same-day cutoff and the 5 to 9 pm window only made sense in a city where a refrigerated cyclist could hit twenty apartments in an hour. for whatever reason, the geographic footprint was always small even at peak, four metros, with san francisco the only one that ever ran close to break-even.

~ what really happened ~

this part is mostly told from the bankruptcy filing and the chefs who leaked to business insider, by then. the 2017 retrenchment from new york and los angeles cut the addressable market by maybe sixty percent. anyway, the san francisco operation was carrying losses on the rest of the company through '17 and '18. for whatever reason, james beriker's '17 to '18 turnaround attempt focused on subscription pricing, family-size meals, and a couple of grocery skus. none of it pulled the unit economics back into shape.

the final week is grim reading. honestly, internal staff reportedly heard about the shutdown the morning of january 21 '19, the customer email went out the same morning, the app stopped accepting orders by midday. for whatever reason, the chefs in the commissary kitchen reportedly arrived to find the doors locked. either way, the formal chapter 7 filing followed within days.

~ what replaced it ~

the munchery shutdown is one of the canonical late-zirp food-delivery flops, sitting beside sprig and maple and bento before it, with grubhub and doordash and uber eats absorbing the prepared-meal demand layer on a different stack. for some reason, the chilled-meal-with-reheat model never came back at scale in the us. honestly, the few attempts since have leaned subscription-frozen or fully hot, the live chef-driven daily-menu approach turned out to be very hard to make money on.

the rolliyo inc. relaunch in october 2020 was a content move, anyway, a recipe site that uses the munchery name and old archived menus, with affiliate links to ingredients. by then, the original munchery.com order flow has been gone for over six years. the san francisco team scattered into other food-tech roles, the original commissary in the bayview industrial corridor was leased to a different kitchen operator within a year.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »