Moneo

1999 - 2015
dead europe
the french banks spent sixteen years trying to make small change feel like a product. moneo kept its balance on the chip rather than in an account, so losing the card lost the money. by 2015 the merchants had mostly stopped accepting it and the students carrying it had never asked for it. the service was switched off on 28 july 2015 and the refund counter stayed open another seven years.

~ the last words ~

On 30 September 1999 the French economy minister Dominique Strauss-Kahn went to Tours to inaugurate a chip. The chip was Moneo, an interbank electronic purse descended from the German Geldkarte, and the pitch was that coins were a nuisance for everyone who handled them. You loaded a few tens of euros onto the card. The merchant put it into a small handheld reader and keyed the amount, and the balance on the chip went down. French law capped the instrument at 30 euros a transaction. It was built for bread and coffee, the kind of payment a card was too expensive to process in 1999.

Two companies ran it, both set up in 1999 by a grouping of the major French banks. Billettique Monétique Services, which later renamed itself Moneo Payment Solutions, handled the technology and the selling. The Société financière du porte-monnaie électronique interbancaire issued the electronic money itself and answered to the banking regulator for it. The French business register has Moneo Payment Solutions incorporated on 16 March 2001 at 2 place de Rio de Janeiro in the eighth arrondissement of Paris, under the earlier name BMS Exploitation. At the end of 2010 a fund managed by BlackFin Capital Partners bought both entities off the banks.

Where Moneo actually moved money was parking meters and universities. The operator claimed 19,000 meters across some 70 French towns, roughly one meter in two, and by 2014 it was telling students that 1.5 million of them carried a Moneo chip, more than 60 percent of the national student body, across 22 of France's 26 académies. That is the number that explains the whole product. Students did not choose Moneo. Their university put it on their student card, and the campus launderette and the photocopier took nothing else. Early in 2009 the company said it was clearing over a million payments a week at an average of 2.20 euros, a figure that has never been independently confirmed. In the first quarter of 2015 Moneo posted a note on its own consumer pages saying the system would be abandoned completely as of 28 July 2015. A regional paper summed it up in a headline that April: for want of users, Moneo is calling it off.

Across all sixteen years of this I was in Turkey, where no bank ever put a spendable balance on the chip of my card. The idea of carrying money as a number on plastic that a baker could decrement is not foreign, but the French version of it was a banking-consortium object with a government minister at the launch, and it never crossed a border in that form. So the figures here are all I have, and I never held one of the cards.

~ the record ~

Born30 September 1999, pilot rollout in Tours
Peakthe operator claimed over a million payments a week in early 2009, average 2.20 euros
Killed28 July 2015
Lifespannearly 16 years
Made byBillettique Monétique Services, later Moneo Payment Solutions, for a grouping of the big French banks
Killed bymerchant fees nobody wanted to pay, plus a balance you could not see

~ how it landed ~

The Geldkarte lineage matters, because Germany had already proven the hard part was not the chip. Moneo copied the architecture and inherited the problem: the money lived on the card. There was no account behind it, which was the selling point for anonymity and the fatal flaw for everything else. Lose the card and you lose the balance, exactly as with cash.

Loading it was its own small ritual. There were dedicated kiosks in bank branches and some signposted ATMs. For a while you could also do it from a PC over the internet, using a smart-card reader on a USB cable that wanted Java and a code from your bank. Some banks would not let their own cards reload at the kiosks, so you bought a top-up on the website and got a single-use number, like a prepaid phone voucher. Anonymous cards were sold on the Moneo site and in some post offices for people without a bank account.

~ inutile et cher ~

The French consumer group UFC-Que Choisir filed the shortest review Moneo ever got: useless and expensive. The expensive part was structural. Cardholders paid to get the card and paid to keep it, merchants paid for the right to accept it, and the float sitting on all those unspent chips belonged to the issuer in the meantime. Merchants did the arithmetic and mostly declined, which left a payment method that was on tens of millions of bank cards and accepted almost nowhere.

The useless part was experiential. You could not see your balance without finding a reader, so the only way to know whether a purchase would clear was to try it. The chip arrived on your bank card whether you had asked for it or not, which produced a large installed base and no demand whatsoever. By 2006 Moneo was trying contactless, and by the time contactless got good the banks were doing it themselves on the ordinary debit rail, where the money was in an account and the limit was not 30 euros.

~ what got buried with it ~

One piece outlived the purse. Moneo-Resto, launched in September 2012 as the first restaurant-voucher card in France, was sold to Edenred in 2017 and its users were moved onto Ticket Restaurant. The student business went partly to Izly, a BPCE product that does the same campus jobs without pretending to be cash. BlackFin, by then the sole shareholder, resolved to wind the company up on 20 December 2022; the register shows its Paris office closed on the 15th of that month. The refund desk is the part that lasted longest. The site at moneo.com is still online today, a single French page with no navigation, and it says the refund service ran until 16 August 2022 and is now permanently closed. Whatever was left on the chips is gone.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a wreath ~

a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.

paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.

» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

other online services: RemarQ, Outbox, Yahoo! Japan Encyclopedia, Dialaphone

also died in 2015-2019: Pottermore, Motribe, Legends of Norrath

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »