Mercata

» see mercata.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the goodbye ~

mercata was a us-only consumer-commerce experiment with a back-end model that needed both broadband penetration and a generation of comfort with online buying. neither existed in 2000, certainly not where i was sitting. i was 16 in turkey, on a 33.6k modem, looking at sites like this as foreign-press novelties. the headline "buy a vcr together with strangers" landed on me as something americans were doing.

tom van horn founded mercata in september 1998 with $9 million from paul allen's vulcan ventures. allen would end up owning about 55% of the company across three rounds totaling close to $90 million. the public site launched in may 1999. mercata called the format "powerbuys": you saw a vcr or a dishwasher listed at a starting price, you committed to buy at whatever the final price ended up being, and the more people committed within the time window, the lower the price dropped. coupon-cutting as a multiplayer game. the marketing pitch was that wholesale-club discounts could be unbundled from costco's parking lot and put on the open web.

then the dot-com crash arrived. mercata had filed an s-1 in september 2000 for a $100 million ipo and by january of the next year nobody on wall street was buying e-commerce stories. mercata withdrew the ipo on january 4, 2001 and announced the shutdown the same week. operations ended on january 31, 2001. tom van horn told reporters that "rejection by both private and public investors" had killed the company, which is dot-com-bust shorthand for the funding rounds it needed to keep operating did not exist.

~ the chronicle ~

~ what it was ~

the powerbuy mechanic was actually clever. each item had a chart of how the price would drop at buyer thresholds, with the steepest cuts kicking in once committed buyers hit the hundreds. you'd commit to buy at the current price and watch the counter climb. people refreshed the page like an auction. the catalog skewed toward white goods and electronics where shaving 30% off was meaningful. there was a referral mechanic. there was a community of "powerbuy hunters" who watched threshold counters across the catalog.

~ the decline ~

the warehouses were the problem. mercata did not actually have inventory. it placed bulk orders with suppliers based on the threshold count at the end of the buy window. that meant logistics were a juggle every time the counter resolved. shipping costs erased whatever margin the group-buy had created. when costco was right there with the same items at similar prices and no waiting period, the model leaked customers in both directions: people who would have bought at the starting price did not need a discount, and people who needed the discount could not be sure when their item would actually ship.

the timing also broke the company. group-buying needs a critical mass of users who trust online purchases enough to commit money to a delayed transaction. in 2000 that population was mostly the same people already buying from amazon at fixed prices. by 2008, when groupon found the same idea, a generation of users had spent a decade buying things online without thinking about it, on a broadband connection that mostly just worked. mercata had the right blueprint and the wrong substrate.

~ the long tail ~

the powerbuy patent was eventually licensed and re-licensed across the 2010s as group-buying clones flowered around the world. groupon's $1.35 billion ipo in 2011 happened on top of a model that mercata had implemented eleven years earlier with a slower internet and a hostile capital market. by 2015 pinduoduo in china had taken the group-buy idea further than groupon ever did, with hundreds of millions of users running threshold buys through wechat. paul allen's $50 million has by then become a mature global category. the failure was not the idea.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »