MadBid

2008 - 2018
dead europe
every bid moved the price up by one penny and reset the clock, and every bid cost you money you did not get back. madbid ran that mechanic out of london for ten years across fourteen countries, took four million pounds from the skype founders' fund to do it, and reached three million registered users before the guardian started picking its listings apart. joint administrators were appointed on 27 june 2018.

~ the obituary ~

The company behind it was Marcandi Limited, number 06609609, entered on the UK register on 3 June 2008 under the trade description of retail sale by mail order or over the internet. Juha Koski, Madhur Srivastava and Daniel Rovira built it without outside money at first, took a seed round in 2009, and in July 2010 raised four million pounds from Atomico, the fund set up by the people who had built Skype. Niklas Zennström's public reason for the investment was that the site let the most skillful bidders get amazing bargains.

The mechanic was already famous by then, because the Munich operation that became Swoopo had been running it since 2005 and the clones were everywhere. You bought credits, between ten and twelve and a half pence each depending on the bundle. A single bid cost anywhere from two to fifteen credits, depending on how popular the auction was. What that bid bought you was one penny on the item's price and up to sixty more seconds on the countdown. Whoever had placed the last bid when the clock finally ran out earned the right to buy the item at that price, plus postage. Everyone else had paid for their bids and received nothing.

MadBid grew fast on that. Revenue went from 1.5 million pounds in 2009 to 7.5 million in 2012, the Sunday Times put it at number 41 in the Tech Track 100 that year, and the company was reporting over three million registered accounts and a million unique page views a week. It was still trading in 2017 on about three million pounds of revenue. Joint administrators from Cork Gully were appointed on 27 June 2018.

~ the case file ~

Born3 June 2008, as Marcandi Limited, company 06609609, London
Peakover three million registered users in 2012; revenue of 7.5 million pounds that year
KilledJune 27 2018, administration; the site stopped selling that August
Lifespan10 years
Made byJuha Koski, Madhur Srivastava and Daniel Rovira
Killed bya model regulators circled for a decade without ever banning

~ the arithmetic ~

The Guardian did the sums in 2012 on a television with a recommended price of 450 pounds, at four credits a bid. The winner paid 217.60 pounds in bids before paying the closing price and the postage. The highest-placed loser paid 211.60 and went home with nothing at all. Across every bidder, MadBid collected 612 pounds on a 450 pound television.

Two features were bolted on to soften that. "Earned Discount" let the money you had burned on losing bids count toward a discount on a direct purchase, valid for a year, and "Buy Now" let you skip the auction entirely. The catch was the base price: the paper found a toaster listed at 49.38 pounds plus delivery under Buy Now that was available elsewhere online for 25 pounds delivered.

Regulators looked at this for ten years and did nothing much. Mark Griffiths, who studies gambling at Nottingham Trent, kept calling for the format to be regulated, and the Gambling Commission kept answering that it did not consider bid-fee auctions to be gambling. The Office of Fair Trading, which had gone after sites that bid automatically against their own customers, said it had nothing to add to work it had already done. The BBC was running pieces on penny auctions coming under scrutiny in December 2008, six months after Marcandi was incorporated.

~ the turkish shopfront ~

MadBid listed fourteen territories it served, and one of them was here. tr.madbid.com has captures in the Archive from December 2013 through at least August 2017, in Turkish, with the page title listing iPhone, laptop, dijital kamera, PS3, LCD TV and araba as the things you could win. The pitch line was Neden mağaza fiyatını ödeyesiniz ki?, which is "why would you pay the shop price", over a promise of savings up to ninety percent.

That window matters to me only because of where I was standing in it. In 2013 I was twenty-nine, salaried, on a fixed line at home, and well past the age where a bid-fee auction looks like anything other than a slot machine with a courier service attached. The Turkish site was still there four years later, so plenty of people were working the sums differently. The honest thing to say is that the format arrived in Turkish, properly localized, with a real company and real logistics behind it, which is exactly what made it harder to dismiss than the banner ads it traveled alongside.

~ the administrators' notice ~

On 15 May 2015 the Guardian ran the piece that did the damage. It had found the same Fiat recorded as having sold for 193 on each of MadBid's three regional sites, with only the currency symbol changing, plus an iPad at 34.40 in all three currencies and a camera at 23.94 in two. MadBid's explanation was that winning bids were mirrored across all three sites by software not sophisticated enough to handle exchange rates, so the number was simply shown unchanged. The same article reported it as the most complained-about company the paper covered.

By late August 2018 madbid.com was one screen of legal text. Stephen Cork and Joanne Milner of Cork Gully LLP had been appointed joint administrators on 27 June, the notice said, and users who believed they were owed money should write to a Cork Gully address. Companies House records the rest without commentary: administration ended 24 January 2019 and rolled straight into creditors' voluntary liquidation the same day, a third liquidator joined in December 2019, the final meeting was returned in March 2021, and the dissolution followed on 24 June 2021. Its last filed accounts covered the year to 30 June 2017. The domain belongs to someone else now, an exchange where you buy and sell social media accounts, which at least keeps it in the family.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »