Google Talk / Hangouts (Classic)

» see talk.google.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the eulogy ~

google talk launched on 24 august 2005. it was a simple instant messenger built on top of XMPP, the open chat protocol. it integrated with gmail. it was clean, fast, and worked. for a few years it was a real alternative to MSN and AIM, especially for people already in the google ecosystem.

then google decided to consolidate. in 2013 google talk was rebranded as hangouts. hangouts was a different product on a different protocol. the XMPP support was deprecated. third-party clients stopped working. existing google talk users were forcibly migrated. some of them stayed. many of them did not.

hangouts itself then went through several more renames. hangouts chat in 2017. google chat in 2020. integration with google workspace and meet. each rename caused confusion about which app to use, what data transferred, and whether your old conversations were still accessible. by november 2022 the consumer hangouts service was officially retired.

~ the dossier ~

~ the original google talk ~

google talk in 2005 was a small product. you logged in with your gmail address. your contact list was based on your gmail contacts. messages were synced with gmail's chat history feature. there was a small embedded chat window in gmail itself, plus a standalone desktop client.

the technical decision to use XMPP was important. XMPP was an open standard. third-party clients (pidgin, adium, jabber clients) could connect to google talk natively. you could be signed into google talk in pidgin alongside MSN, AIM, ICQ, and Yahoo, all in one combined contact list. for nerds with cross-network friend groups, this was the dream setup.

i used google talk through pidgin from about 2008 to 2013. it was reliable. the message history sync with gmail was actually useful. you could search your old conversations from years ago. when google killed XMPP support and forced everyone to hangouts in 2013, my pidgin setup broke and i never really fixed it. i moved to using whatsapp web for chat after that.

~ the rename spiral ~

google's messenger product line between 2013 and 2022 had at least six different products with overlapping but not identical features:

• google talk (consumer XMPP, retired 2017)
• hangouts (consumer, 2013-2022)
• hangouts chat (enterprise, 2017+)
• google chat (rename of hangouts chat, 2020+)
• google meet (video conferencing, separate)
• google allo (a different consumer messenger, 2016-2019, also dead)
• google duo (video calling, 2016-2022, merged into meet)

this list is partial. there were also smaller products that briefly existed and died. google had multiple messenger teams running in parallel for years, each shipping a different product, none of which became dominant. while this was happening, whatsapp was eating the international consumer market and slack was eating the enterprise.

~ the curtain ~

the consumer hangouts service was officially retired in november 2022. users were migrated to google chat. the migration lost some conversation history because chat is structured differently from hangouts. some users found their data was incomplete after the move.

google chat itself is still alive in 2026 as part of google workspace. it works. it is mostly used by google workspace customers as part of their corporate email setup. the consumer messenger business is effectively gone. people who wanted to chat with their friends on google products gave up around 2018.

~ what we lost ~

the open protocol consumer messenger. google talk's XMPP support meant you could use any third-party client. when google killed it, the open-protocol consumer messenger ecosystem effectively died. no major service since has supported a similar open standard. signal is encrypted but not federated. matrix is federated but small. for the consumer market, the era of "any client can talk to any service" ended with google talk.

the gmail-integrated chat. there was a specific shape of "your chat is in your inbox" that google talk got right. the chat window was in your gmail tab. the conversation history was searchable like email. modern messengers are separate apps. that integration is hard to recreate.

the trust that google would not break it. when google killed XMPP support in 2013 they broke a lot of working integrations. when they consolidated hangouts to google chat they broke conversation history. each consolidation cost trust. by 2020 nobody was building serious tools on google's chat APIs because the APIs would probably change in 18 months.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »