Franchise Pictures

1997 - 2004
dead us
the budget on battlefield earth was declared at $75 million. the bank records produced at trial said $44 million, and the gap between those two numbers is what a federal jury in santa ana spent the summer of 2004 looking at. elie samaha had built a film company on foreign presales and german tax money, picking up stars whose projects had stalled at the majors and shooting them cheap. judgment went in against him and seventeen other parties for $121,690,060, and the company filed chapter 11 two days after that. in 2006 the whole judgment settled for $3 million.

~ the obit ~

Elie Samaha owned a dry cleaning business and the Roxbury on Sunset before he owned a film company. Franchise Pictures started in October 1997 and the Delaware entity was organized on 23 April 1998, with Ashok Amritraj alongside him at the beginning and Andrew Stevens running it as president. The method was simple enough to explain at a party: find an actor whose passion project the studios had passed on, agree to make it for less than the studios would have, and sell the foreign rights before a camera turned.

Money arrived from Germany. In 1999 the Munich company Intertainment AG agreed to fund a slate of 60 Franchise films, a commitment reported at $750 million, in exchange for European rights, and the deal was that Intertainment would pay 47 percent of each production budget. Commerzbank put in $180 million through film funds. Warner Bros. handled domestic release for a 15 percent fee. For about two years this looked like a working business and it produced one real hit, The Whole Nine Yards, which took $106 million worldwide in 2000 off a $41 million budget.

The problem with paying a percentage of a budget is that somebody has to say what the budget is. Intertainment ended up paying between 60 and 90 percent of real costs instead of the 47 it had agreed to, because the numbers it was given were not the numbers being spent. It sued in December 2000 in the federal court at Santa Ana. The case needed three and a half years plus several postponements before it reached a jury.

On 16 June 2004 the jury found fraud and awarded $77.1 million in compensatory damages, assigning them to Franchise Pictures rather than to Samaha personally, and rejecting a $345 million racketeering claim that would have tripled everything. Two days later it added $29 million in punitive damages, $4 million of that against Samaha himself and $1.5 million against each of sixteen production companies. Judge Alicemarie H. Stotler entered final judgment of $121,690,060 on 16 August 2004. Franchise Pictures LLC filed for Chapter 11 on the 18th, listing over $100 million in liabilities and more than 200 creditors.

~ the rap sheet ~

BornOctober 1997 in Los Angeles, with the Delaware LLC organized 23 April 1998
Peaka 1999 commitment from Intertainment AG covering 60 films, worth $750 million
Killed18 August 2004, Chapter 11 in the Central District of California
Lifespan7 years, with 47 titles released under the name
Made byElie Samaha, who owned a dry cleaning chain and a Sunset Strip nightclub first
Killed bya $121,690,060 fraud judgment entered two days before the filing

~ how the money worked ~

Franchise was not a studio in any structural sense. It was a financing shape: foreign presales and German tax shelter funds, with a distributor taking a fee off the top in North America. Nothing in that is unusual on its own and most of the independent business ran on some version of it. What made Franchise distinct was volume and casting. It made 47 films in seven years, and the names on them were real ones, John Travolta and Bruce Willis and Sylvester Stallone and Kurt Russell, generally in the picture their regular studio had declined to make.

The films themselves are a strange list to read now. Sean Penn directed The Pledge for them, with Jack Nicholson, and it is a good film. David Mamet made Heist. There is a Get Carter remake that lost most of its $63.6 million budget, a Rob Reiner comedy, a Steve Buscemi prison picture, and 3000 Miles to Graceland, which cost $47.4 million and took $18.7 million. The Boondock Saints went out through them. The one consistent quality across the catalog is that each film cost a great deal more on paper than anybody watching it would guess.

~ thirty one million dollars ~

Battlefield Earth is the exhibit everyone remembers, though not because it was bad. It premiered at Grauman's Chinese on 10 May 2000, went wide two days later and took $29.7 million worldwide. The budget declared to Intertainment was $75 million. At trial Intertainment produced bank records showing that about $44 million had actually been spent, leaving $31 million of padding in a single film's paperwork. Its chief executive Barry Baeres testified that when he raised the budgets with Samaha, Samaha told him it was called packaging.

The Pledge had the same shape at a smaller scale, declared at $55 million against a real cost of about $37 million. Across the slate, Intertainment alleged the inflation ran as high as $124 million. Franchise's defense at trial was not that the budgets were accurate. It admitted they were inflated and argued that Intertainment had known all along, had not actually agreed to pay on the basis of the stated budgets, and had suggested the practice in the first place. The jury did not buy it.

~ what three million bought ~

In August 2006 Intertainment settled the whole $121.7 million judgment against Samaha and his holding company for $3 million, payable in two installments by that December, plus ownership of roughly a hundred production and distribution shells he had controlled before the bankruptcy. That is about two and a half cents on the dollar. The bankruptcy itself ran for years: a plan was confirmed on 26 March 2010 and the case closed on 1 April 2013, by which time the library had been split between Orange Holdings and, through Morgan Creek, Revolution Studios.

Samaha never filed personally and never left the business. He launched Luminosity Entertainment in September 2021, announcing plans for fifteen films in two years at budgets up to $50 million, and he holds a stake in the TCL Chinese Theatre along with a former Warner Bros. studio facility outside Bucharest. The company is the thing that died. The films are all still watchable, at the budgets they were really made for.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a wreath ~

a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.

paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.

» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

other dot com: Bidville, Play.com, Petopia.com, TinyOwl

also died in the 2000s: Marconi, Navini Networks, Infopop (UBB.classic)

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »