CNN Checkout Channel
~ the obituary ~
The idea came from Richard Larsen, a professor at MIT who studied queues for a living and told reporters his colleagues called him Dr. Q. Waiting in a supermarket checkout line, he said, was something everyone did daily, under high levels of stress and frustration, and it amounted to a subtle form of imprisonment. His proposal was to convert that empty time into something informative. What the proposal became was a short news loop with commercials in it, bolted to the ceiling above the conveyor belt.
The announcement came on 19 September 1990: a joint venture pairing the in-store marketing company ActMedia, of Darien, Connecticut, with CNN. ActMedia carried the startup cost, which the Chicago Tribune put at sixty to seventy-five million dollars, and handled distribution into the chains. CNN produced the newswheel and kept complete editorial control, with a permanent staff of thirty under Jon Petrovich. Turner Broadcasting took an option on an equity position and ran the service through Turner Private Networks. It went live in seven cities that week, after a test at a Kroger in Detroit where hidden cameras and exit interviews reportedly found 87 percent of customers liked it.
The wider rollout came in February 1992, into about 150 stores across fourteen markets, from Akron and Greensboro to Phoenix and Salt Lake City, inside A&P, Kroger, Finast and Acme. Turner paid for all of the hardware, including the satellite dish on the roof, which A&P's Michael Rourke described as a major asset in its own right because the store could use it for internal communications. ActMedia sold the advertising nationally, in quarterly and annual packages with category exclusivity, at rates its president Wayne LoCurto said matched any network's daytime placement.
ActMedia had told the trade press the channel would reach at least 5,000 stores within two years, which it put conservatively at sixty million impressions a week. By year three it expected seventy-five to a hundred million dollars from advertisers. It got to 840 stores in seventeen markets, and stopped there.
~ the case file ~
| Born | February 1992, in 150 stores across 14 markets |
|---|---|
| Peak | 840 stores in 17 markets, more than 10,000 television sets |
| Killed | Announced 18 February 1993, dark by the end of March |
| Lifespan | About 13 months |
| Made by | Turner Private Networks and ActMedia, of Darien, Connecticut |
| Killed by | A $16 million write-down, and shoppers who had already decided |
~ eight minutes ~
The programming was engineered backwards from one measurement. Eight minutes was the researched average time an American stood in a supermarket checkout line, so that was the length of the newswheel, updated through the day. By the 1992 rollout the segments ran around ten minutes, with commercials of fifteen and thirty seconds taking about forty percent of the airtime.
The content was cut-down CNN Headline News: rapid-fire summaries and short features, with the ability to go live in short form if something large broke while people were buying groceries. There were three distinct dayparts, re-edited by who was expected to be in the store, with features aimed at women around midday and sports played up later on.
Five charter advertisers signed at the announcement, among them Disney, Kraft, Planters and Ford. By the February 1992 rollout more than eighty percent of the inventory was sold, to Coca-Cola, Kimberly Clark, Nabisco and People magazine. A Turner spokeswoman confirmed that same week that the company was negotiating with McDonald's about a version for people eating in restaurants. That one never launched.
~ what the cashiers said ~
The Associated Press went to an A&P in Atlanta for the rollout. A shopper said it was fine, something to do while waiting. Another pointed at her 23-month-old son and called it a great distraction for him. Then the reporter spoke to the cashier working underneath the monitor, Anne McIntyre, who had done two straight hours beneath it and wanted a break. The same commercials over and over, she said, were driving her crazy.
That complaint turned out to be the structural one. By the following spring, many cashiers had turned the volume down so far that the news and the commercials were both barely audible, which removed the only reason an advertiser was paying. There was a second effect nobody had modeled: shoppers who did watch slowed the lines down, because they stopped doing the things people do while queueing, like getting their identification out or filling in a check.
The Philadelphia Inquirer interviewed about half a dozen shoppers at an Acme in Westmont, New Jersey, and reported that not one of them expressed anything but indifference. One was reading Cosmopolitan. Acme's Ed Spragg gave the official version, which was that reactions were mixed and the predominant number of people did not respond to the screens at all. Martin Sloane, writing in The Daily Gazette, found the commercial flaw underneath all of it: the advertising arrived about half an hour too late, because by the time a shopper glanced up they had already decided what they were buying and were not going to give up their place in line to go back for something else.
~ sixteen million ~
Turner announced the shutdown on Thursday 18 February 1993, folded into its fourth-quarter earnings, where it appeared as a sixteen million dollar charge against a quarter whose profit fell thirty percent. Turner's stated reason was that the network needed more investment than projected to reach profitability. Paul Beckham, who ran Turner Private Networks, insisted it was primarily a financial decision and that the response from the advertisers and the chains had been good. An expansion that would have added several thousand more stores for another thirty-five million was canceled with it. Stores that wanted to keep the hardware were offered a plain CNN Headline News feed.
The verdict from outside was less kind. Alan Gottesman at PaineWebber said the channel had simply recycled programming instead of crafting it for the environment, and that it bore no relation to the environment of a supermarket. Turner, by one account, had spent the last months trying to produce research proving the commercials were worth something, and never managed it. NBC On-Site inherited the field within a fortnight, putting silent screens in the aisles rather than at the register, and hired Nielsen on day one to measure who was watching.
~ what Larsen was right about ~
In February 1992 I was a child several thousand kilometers from any of this, in a country with no cable industry to speak of, where a grocery queue contained nothing but the queue. The screens that did eventually turn up in Turkish queues went into banks and government offices, and all they ever did was count ticket numbers.
The sibling service lived. The airport channel ran its pilot in the summer of 1991, launched properly on 20 January 1992 and stayed on until 31 March 2021, because an airport wait is measured in hours and offers no alternative. The checkout wait is eight minutes and ends in a transaction you finished thinking about in aisle four. What makes the whole thing worth remembering is that the queueing theorist was not wrong. Rourke told Time that shoppers who had waited five minutes usually guessed twelve to fifteen if there was no television, and three or four if there was. The screens did what Larsen designed them to do. They shortened the wait by about ten minutes, in the only place a wait is actually measured, and nobody could work out how to sell that.
~ leave a rose ~
an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.
@}-->-- ... roses left here
~ leave a wreath ~
a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.
paid once through stripe. payments are handled by OÜ Lakeview, the small company that keeps rip.so running. the money pays for the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.
» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe
other phenomena: goatse.cx, Simulmatics Corporation, Hot or Not, Orange Wednesdays
also died in the 1990s: BYTE Magazine, Games-X, Mega
~ leave a note ~
visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.