Clash (clash.me)

~ how it landed ~

i never used clash. i was not on tiktok either. by august 2020 i was 36, working as a computer engineer in turkey, and the entire short-form-video creator economy was something i read about in techcrunch and never opened on the phone. byte had already launched in january 2020 from vine's own founder dom hofmann and was winding down by year end. clash was the third attempt at this thing.

brendon mcnerney built it. he had been near the top of vine's earner list before twitter shut vine down in october 2016, watched most creators get paid nothing for years, and watched them all walk to musical.ly which became tiktok. his pitch for clash was simple. the platform pays the creators, and creators get paid first. tiktok was already bigger than vine ever was, already famous for not paying anyone outside its own creator fund, and was not going to commit. clash said it would.

~ the byte deal ~

in january 2021 clash bought byte. the closest thing to a vine 2.0 burying another vine 2.0. dom hofmann had spent two years on byte and earned zero from it. clash absorbed the app, kept the byte brand briefly for nostalgia, then merged everything under the clash name in october 2021. the new app launched on the us app store as a creator+fans product. you could tip creators directly. creators could see who their actual top fans were.

i did not install it. by then i had been online for 23 years and had watched enough of these "next vine" cycles to know the math. tiktok had over a billion monthly active users that quarter. clash was somewhere under a million. the founder thesis can be clean and the platform can still lose at that ratio.

~ the huddles pivot ~

in 2022 mcnerney announced clash would pivot. no more feed scroll, no more vine 2.0 third attempt. it would become a group chat product for creators and their close-circle fans. they rebranded to huddles in june 2022 and removed the public feed entirely. by then the original headline thesis (creators get paid first) was no longer the headline. it was a smaller idea now, and a smaller team chasing it.

~ how it actually ended ~

on 3 may 2023 huddles posted "dear creators" on medium and announced shutdown. the app was pulled from the us app stores in waves over the following weeks. data export was offered. creators got their content out. no acquirer, no follow-on product, no broader landing page.

what stayed buried with clash was the cleanest attempt to fix the actual vine problem. mcnerney had identified the right hole. creators on vine had made nothing, walked to a platform that would pay them, and platforms learned the wrong lesson, which was that creators could be retained without payment. clash said no, and meant it, but never reached the size where the network effect could carry the payment cost. tiktok kept all the oxygen in the room. by 2023 nobody was launching another one of these.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »