c2it

» see c2it.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obituary ~

Banks were supposed to win this one. Moving money between two people is the oldest thing a bank does, it is regulated in the bank's favor, and in 2000 the largest consumer bank in the world looked at PayPal and concluded that a startup handling payments was a temporary condition. Citibank built c2it and expected the argument to end there.

The product was email money. You attached an account from whatever institution you already used, typed a recipient's email address, and the money went. That is close enough to what PayPal did that the difference had to come from somewhere else, so Citi's answer was distribution. It launched as a partnership with AOL and later added CompuServe and Microsoft.

On paper that was the strongest hand at the table. AOL in 2000 was the front door to the American internet and Citibank was the balance sheet standing behind it. PayPal at that point was a company that had merged with X.com earlier the same year and was losing money on every transaction it processed.

I was nowhere near any of this. Sending money to another person in Turkey in 2003 meant a bank transfer done at a branch or through a website that only worked in Internet Explorer, and PayPal itself would not properly matter here for years afterward. This is a fight that happened inside one country's retail banking market. The reason it earns a grave is that the loser was the one everybody expected to win.

~ the case file ~

~ the number ~

Gartner asked American consumers in 2002 which person-to-person payment service they used. PayPal came back at thirty-three percent. Citibank's came back at one. Three years of a bank's name and AOL's front page produced one percent.

The reason is not mysterious. PayPal had eBay, and eBay was where the transactions were. Citi cut its transaction fees in 2001 specifically to go after the auction market, which was the correct diagnosis and roughly two years too late to act on, because by then buyers and sellers had already settled among themselves on what they were using. A payment network is worth exactly the number of people on the other side of it, and that is not a thing a marketing budget can buy.

~ how it was switched off ~

Citigroup announced the end in September 2003. On 9 November the transaction side went dark, with remaining balances mailed out as checks. The website stayed up in a reduced form so people could read old statements and change their details, and in February 2004 that came down too.

It is a tidy shutdown, which is what happens when the operator is a bank rather than a startup. Nobody lost money, there was a notice period, the funds came back in the most boring instrument available. eBay had bought PayPal for $1.5 billion the year before c2it closed.

One footnote from the archive. There was already a small barcode-scanning company called C2it, Inc. sitting on that domain when Citibank picked the name in 2000, and after the bank was finished with it the address went back to a company of that name. It is there in 2026, on a page built in GoDaddy's site builder. The barcode company outlasted Citigroup's payments product by more than twenty years.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »