Blue Mars

2009 - 2011
dead us
blue mars was the honolulu-based virtual world platform from avatar reality that opened public beta in september 2009 with the pitch of being a next-generation second life. it ran on the crytek cryengine 2 and shipped with a developer economy where creators could sell items for real money through a blue mars dollar currency. peak registration crossed 50,000 accounts by late 2010 with only about a tenth of that active in the client. avatar reality cut two-thirds of its staff in january 2011 and announced the pc client was being wound down in favor of a lighter ios and browser strategy. neither replacement landed. in 2012 the underlying technology was licensed to ball state university for research use.

~ the obituary ~

i missed blue mars. the beta opened in september 2009 and by then i was 25, well past the age when i would have signed up for a fresh virtual world just to see what the avatar creator did. the platform's biggest year was 2010 and its biggest year happened almost entirely inside the small english-language virtual-worlds press. metaverse journal, new world notes, the various second life bloggers who covered the neighboring platforms. the news reached me later, mostly in retrospectives about why second life competitors kept failing.

avatar reality was a honolulu startup put together around 2008 by a group that included former square enix and lucasarts staff. the pitch was clean: cryengine 2 for the graphics, per-city hosting so a landowner could operate a separate world on the same client, an in-world currency called blue mars dollars that could be cashed out to paypal. the beta opened on 2 september 2009 as a windows-only download of about 2 gigabytes. the first year of coverage was warm, mostly framed as second life's first credible next-generation challenger.

by the end of 2010 the numbers were about 50,000 registered accounts and a much smaller active pool, described in different reports as roughly 3,500 people on the beta forums. the developer economy never reached the scale that would make hosting a city profitable. cryengine 2 also required a windows pc strong enough to run a mid-2000s aaa game, which cut off a large slice of the second life crossover audience that avatar reality had been counting on.

~ the case file ~

Bornpublic beta 2 september 2009 for windows pc, developed by avatar reality in honolulu
Peakapproximately 50,000 registered accounts by late 2010, with roughly 10% active in the client
Killedpc client development halted january 2011 after avatar reality cut its team from 30 to 10 people
Lifespanabout 16 months of active client development
Made byavatar reality inc., ceo jim sink
Killed byinsufficient user base to sustain the developer economy, cash burn on a cryengine-heavy pc client

~ the pitch ~

what made blue mars sound plausible at the time was the split-hosting model. avatar reality would run the platform and the avatar system, and independent developers would license their own city space to populate with buildings and events, taking a cut of anything sold in that city. it looked like a franchise pyramid rather than second life's flat landmass. that structure required enough shoppers moving between cities to sustain a shopkeeper economy. the shopkeeper economy never quite got there.

~ the actual end ~

avatar reality announced on 15 january 2011 that it was cutting staff from about 30 to about 10 and refocusing away from the pc client. the plan named was a lighter ios application plus a browser-facing "lite" version that used google street view as a chat backdrop. the pc client was left running but development stopped. by 2012 the company had granted expanded technology rights to ball state university for 3d simulation research, valued in the announcement at $10 million of r&d work. the consumer product effectively ended there.

~ the long tail ~

blue mars sits in a small pile of second life competitors that shipped in the late 2000s and could not build the audience needed to survive their own hosting costs. sony home came from the console side, google lively from the browser side. there.com had been running since 2003. smallworlds and imvu each held their own slice. what blue mars had that most of them did not was the graphics engine and a coherent economic model. what it did not have was enough people willing to install a heavy client and hang around waiting for the shops to fill.

~ leave a rose ~

an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.

@}-->-- ... roses left here

~ leave a wreath ~

a rose fades by morning. a wreath stays on this grave for good, with your name on it.

from $1, paid once through stripe. it keeps the graveyard running: the hosting and the nightly digging. adopt it and the headstone reads "maintained in memory by" you. the groundskeeper plants new wreaths at the next tending, usually within a day.

» one email a week: new graves and the anniversaries of the dead. subscribe

~ leave a note ~

visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.

other gaming: CRL Group, The 3DO Company, Xbox Live Arcade, Mafia Wars

also died in 2010-2014: Wupload, Final Cut Express, VirginMega.fr

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »