aQuantive

» see aquantive.com as it lived, on the wayback machine

~ the obituary ~

aquantive sat in the part of microsoft's catalog i never interacted with directly. it was an enterprise ad-tech holding company, the kind of thing that mattered to chief revenue officers at agencies in new york and not to a computer engineer in ankara. the only reason most people outside the ad industry ever heard of aquantive is the writedown. on 2 july 2012 microsoft disclosed a 6.2 billion dollar non-cash impairment charge tied almost entirely to the aquantive purchase from five years earlier. that number was, at the time, the largest single tech-acquisition write-off anyone had ever booked.

the company itself was a seattle dot-com survivor. nick hanauer and a small team had founded the original ad agency, avenue a, in 1997. through the next decade they bought atlas (an ad-server platform) and razorfish (a flagship digital agency from the first dot-com boom). by 2005 aquantive was a holding company with avenue a/razorfish on the agency side and atlas dmt on the ad-server side, plus a smaller drive performance solutions arm doing third-party analytics. it was a real business with real revenue, not a story-stock.

the microsoft acquisition was announced on 18 may 2007. the price was six billion dollars in cash, the largest acquisition in microsoft's history until skype in 2011. the deal closed on 10 august 2007. the strategic logic was: google had bought doubleclick a month earlier for 3.1 billion, microsoft needed an ad-tech equivalent or it would be locked out of display advertising during a period when display was still expected to scale alongside search.

the integration never worked. microsoft ran aquantive as the advertiser and publisher solutions group inside a sales organization that was built around windows licensing, which had different incentives. razorfish was eventually sold to publicis in 2009 for a fraction of its book value, and that division is now part of publicis groupe rather than dead. atlas was the ad server. microsoft sold atlas to facebook in february 2013 for an undisclosed sum smaller than what microsoft had paid for the whole holding. facebook ran atlas for three more years before sunsetting it in 2016. on 2 july 2012 microsoft formally took the 6.2 billion impairment, which essentially declared the entire acquisition value gone.

~ the case file ~

~ what microsoft was buying ~

the strategic pitch for aquantive in early 2007 was that display advertising on the open web was about to scale into a hundred billion dollar market, and any company that wanted to be part of that needed both an ad server and an agency relationship in the same building. google had moved first with doubleclick a month before the microsoft announcement. yahoo had bought right media around the same time. microsoft buying aquantive completed the consolidation that the press had been writing about since 2005.

the problem was that the open-web display market did not scale into a hundred billion dollar market on the timeline anyone had projected. mobile arrived faster than expected, and ad spend concentrated into facebook and google instead of spreading across the open web. the third-party ad server became less important than the walled-garden ad platform. aquantive's whole product portfolio assumed an open ad market that was already starting to close as the deal was being signed.

~ the writeoff ~

the 6.2 billion charge on 2 july 2012 was disclosed in an 8-k filing that ran less than a page. microsoft phrased it as a writedown of goodwill tied to the online services division, which contained aquantive. the timing was tied to the company's fiscal year close, not to a specific incident inside the division. it was just an acknowledgment that the carrying value of aquantive on the balance sheet was higher than any reasonable estimate of its future cash flows.

the press read the filing immediately. the story for the next three days was that microsoft had effectively confirmed its first big public-market acquisition mistake of the steve ballmer era. business-school case studies started using the deal within a year as an example of acquirer overpayment under competitive pressure from a rival deal.

~ the long tail ~

the subsidiaries had different fates. razorfish kept operating under publicis after the 2009 sale and is still a working agency in 2026; avenue a had already been folded into razorfish by then. atlas got sold to facebook in 2013 and ran as atlas by facebook until 2016. nick hanauer went on to become a public commentator on inequality and capitalism, more famous now for political writing than for the company he had built.

microsoft itself eventually re-entered ad-tech through bing ads and later linkedin, both of which became more important than the aquantive bet ever did. the 6.2 billion impairment kept being cited until the 7.6 billion nokia writedown in 2015 quietly took its place as the largest microsoft-acquisition write-off.

@}-->--

              )
             (_)
            .-'-.
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
            |   |
          __|   |__   .-.
       .-'  |   |  `-:   :
      :     `---'     :-'
       `-._       _.-'
           '""""""

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »