MetaFilter

» go to metafilter.com now (it still works)

~ what it is ~

in 1999 the word weblog was new enough that building one for strangers to share was a novel idea. matt haughey put MetaFilter online on july 14, 1999, as a community weblog. one front page, links posted by members, a comment thread under each. no votes, no karma, no algorithm. the newest post sits on top until a newer one arrives. that design has now survived twenty seven years without meaningful change.

the subsite that actually conquered the world is ask metafilter, launched in 2003. members ask questions, other members answer, and because the members skew literate and forty, the answers are good. for two decades a healthy fraction of my google results for genuinely hard life questions ended at a green ask metafilter page. i suspect the same is true for you.

~ the five dollar door ~

membership was free at first, and the site kept closing signups because growth was breaking it. the fix, in november 2004, was a five dollar one-time fee. not a subscription. five dollars, once, forever. it was never about revenue. it was a speed bump that filtered out drive-by trolls and spammers while barely inconveniencing anyone sincere. twenty two years later the price has not changed, which may be the only price on the internet that has not.

~ the humans in the loop ~

MetaFilter pays human moderators to read the site around the clock. not volunteers, not contractors reviewing flagged queues, actual staff who know the regulars by name. this is the single feature no large platform has ever been willing to fund, and it is why metafilter comment threads from 2007 are still readable and youtube comments from 2007 are not.

~ what almost killed it ~

google. a november 2012 algorithm update quietly buried the site, and ask metafilter lost about 40 percent of its traffic, which meant ad revenue collapsed. in may 2014 haughey laid off three moderators and wrote publicly about the site's decline. by 2018 it was losing 8,000 dollars a month. haughey handed ownership to josh millard in 2017, millard passed it to jessamyn west in 2022, and in december 2024 the site began its transition to the metafilter community foundation, a nonprofit. around 47,000 active members and member donations now keep seven staff paid.

~ why it still matters ~

every other community from its era either sold, scaled, or died. kuro5hin is a grave. memepool is a grave. MetaFilter chose a fourth option, stay small, charge five dollars, pay the moderators, and eventually hand the keys to the community itself. it is quieter than it was in 2009, but the front page updates every day, and the conversation is still worth reading, which after twenty seven years might be the rarest sentence on this site.

« previous  ·  random  ·  next »