47th Street Photo
~ the goodbye ~
47th Street Photo opened in 1967 in the diamond district of midtown Manhattan, and the New York Times would later credit it with having helped invent the whole idea of discount consumer electronics retailing in that city. It sold cameras first and then sold everything: stereos, calculators, video recorders, eventually computers. The name confused people permanently, because tourists would come in asking for 47th Street Camera and the shop had not been only a camera shop for years.
What turned a Manhattan counter into a national institution was the mail order. If you lived in Ohio in 1985 and wanted a lens or a printer below the price on the box, you found a small-print advertisement in the back pages of a magazine, dialed New York, and spoke to someone who read a number off a sheet. There was a warehouse in Brooklyn behind all of that. The store's reputation crossed the country on price lists rather than on anything resembling marketing.
Then the format it had pioneered was industrialized by people with more capital. Warehouse-scale discounters could buy deeper than a five-store operation in midtown, and in its own city the shop was fighting Crazy Eddie, Newmark and Lewis, Tops Appliance City, P.C. Richard & Son and The Wiz, most of which also failed during the 1990s. The 47th Street location closed during a downturn, three more followed it, and in January 1992 the company filed for Chapter 11.
Everything above is a story that needed two things Turkey did not have. Discount by mail order needs a continental postal market, and it needs a magazine industry fat enough to carry four pages of small type in the back of every issue. Buying hardware cheaply here meant going to a shop and dealing with a person who was also the person who would fix it afterward, which is a different transaction with a different kind of trust in it. The shop closed the year before I first dialed up, so the entire genre of nostalgia about telephoning New York for a price reaches me secondhand, through other people's forum posts about ads in magazines I never saw.
~ the chronicle ~
| Born | 1967, in the diamond district of midtown Manhattan |
|---|---|
| Peak | five stores plus a national mail-order business run out of a Brooklyn warehouse |
| Killed | 1997, after five years in Chapter 11; no single closing day was ever published |
| Lifespan | 30 years |
| Made by | an independent New York retailer; the New York Times credited it with pioneering discount electronics retailing in the city |
| Killed by | the discount superstores that industrialized its own format, and a bankruptcy that ended in a fraud conviction |
~ the shop floor ~
The Times, writing the day after the 1992 filing, produced the best sentence anyone managed about the place: no other store seemed to have so much merchandise and so few displays. There was no showroom logic. The stock was simply present, in bulk, and a customer quoted in the same piece summarized the experience by saying that any time you came in, you had to wait.
Bankruptcy did nothing to the crowds. The paper's headline on that visit called it a bankrupt but still popular mecca, and the shop went on trading in exactly that condition for another five years, with the Brooklyn warehouse still filling mail orders behind it.
~ five years of chapter 11 ~
The ending will not resolve into a date, and this grave is filed at year precision on purpose. In 1995 the name was licensed out to a separate management team, who inherited the job of presiding over the closure. On 27 March 1997 the Times ran a piece headlined on the store closing its doors with a questionable future. Later that year a court-appointed trustee was handling what remained, against a background of fraud allegations aimed at the owners. No source published a final day, and the company's disestablishment is recorded only as a year.
The legal case outlived the business. Fresh charges were filed in September 1997, and in March 1998 the former owner was convicted of fraud. In the same stretch of months the Times was writing up Willoughby's, a camera dealer a few blocks away that dated back to 1898, for successfully remaking itself for the digital era. One of those two businesses had spent thirty years teaching America to buy electronics at a discount, and the one still standing was the hundred-year-old shop that had never been cheap.
~ leave a rose ~
an anonymous tribute. one rose per visitor per day.
@}-->-- ... roses left here
~ leave a note ~
visitors before you have left these graveside notes. anonymous welcome.